Posted in

More Than A Million Slices Sold: See Why This Baraboo Restaurant’s Pies Are A Sweet Sensation

Published: July 28, 2025

Step inside what feels like a wilderness retreat right in the heart of Baraboo, and you’ll discover why this authentic log cabin has become a Wisconsin dining institution.

Built from eleven-inch pine logs in 1993, Log Cabin Family Restaurant isn’t just serving comfort food—they’re creating edible memories with every meal.

What started as a small bakery focused on fresh pies has blossomed into a beloved gathering place that’s welcomed over 3.5 million guests through its doors.

The impressive milestone of selling more than one million slices of pie speaks volumes about what awaits you here.

This isn’t your typical family restaurant; it’s a culinary destination where homestyle cooking meets genuine hospitality in an atmosphere that transports you to a cozy Northwoods retreat.

You Can Find A Grass-Fed Wisconsin Burger And A Farmhouse Wood-Fired Pizza At This Wausau Brewery Related

More in Wisconsin

You Can Find A Grass-Fed Wisconsin Burger And A Farmhouse Wood-Fired Pizza At This Wausau Brewery

Keep Exploring →

Menu Highlights

The Famous Fresh-Baked Pies: You’ll find an incredible selection of over a dozen pie varieties made fresh daily, from classic apple and cherry to indulgent chocolate silk and peanut butter cream. The unique coconut graham cracker crust on their Key Lemon pie sets it apart from ordinary desserts, while seasonal specialties like pumpkin and peach keep the offerings exciting year-round.

Seven Daily Fresh Breads: Each morning brings a new selection of artisanal breads baked on-site, including their standout cinnamon pear bread that diners consistently rave about. You can choose any of these warm, fragrant breads as your side instead of traditional dinner rolls, and many guests leave with whole loaves to take home.

All-Day Breakfast Excellence: The Log Cabin Nest—their signature “egg-in-the-hole” dish—has earned a devoted following among locals and visitors alike. Their thick-cut smoked bacon, fresh-cut hash browns, and farm-fresh eggs create breakfast combinations that satisfy even the heartiest appetites well into the afternoon.

Slow-Roasted Meats: The kitchen takes pride in slow-roasting and smoking their own beef, pork, turkey, and ribs on-site. Weekend prime rib dinners on Saturday and Sunday showcase this commitment to quality, while their Friday fish fry maintains the beloved Wisconsin tradition with perfectly crispy results.

Comfort Food Classics: The chicken pot pie stands out as a Sunday specialty, featuring a flaky golden crust filled with tender chicken and vegetables. Their country-style dinners come with your choice of two sides, making every meal feel like a home-cooked feast prepared by someone who truly cares.

A Beloved Wisconsin Bar Rose From The Ashes To Serve One Of The State’s Best All-Day Fish Frys

More in Wisconsin

A Beloved Wisconsin Bar Rose From The Ashes To Serve One Of The State’s Best All-Day Fish Frys

Discover More

Creative Waffle Specialties: Beyond traditional breakfast fare, you’ll discover inventive options like the Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup waffle topped with whipped cream and chocolate syrup, or the Banana Strawberry waffle that transforms morning dining into a dessert-like experience.

Atmosphere & Décor

Authentic Log Construction: The restaurant’s genuine log cabin architecture creates an immediately welcoming atmosphere, with eleven-inch pine logs assembled by craftsmen from Black River Falls forming the foundation of this rustic retreat.

Northwoods-Inspired Interior: Two stone fireplaces anchor the dining space, while unique wood carvings throughout the restaurant add character and charm. The décor feels authentically woodsy without being overdone, creating a comfortable environment where families naturally gather.

Spacious Family-Friendly Layout: The generous dining room accommodates everything from intimate couples’ meals to large family gatherings, with one area specifically designed to seat parties of 13 or more. The open layout prevents the cramped feeling often found in smaller restaurants, even during busy weekend rushes.

Cozy Lighting and Ambiance: The warm, inviting atmosphere makes every meal feel special, whether you’re stopping by for a quick breakfast or settling in for a leisurely dinner. The rustic charm creates a perfect backdrop for both casual meals and special celebrations.

From Homemade Chicken Dumpling Soup To A Bloody Mary That’s A Meal, This Eagle River Spot Is A Must-Try Related

More in Wisconsin

From Homemade Chicken Dumpling Soup To A Bloody Mary That’s A Meal, This Eagle River Spot Is A Must-Try

Keep Exploring →

Other Considerations

Exceptional Value: You’ll find the pricing remarkably reasonable for the quality and portion sizes offered. At under $4 per slice, the fresh-baked pies represent an outstanding value, and the option to substitute pie for one of your dinner sides adds even more appeal to the overall dining experience.

Family-Friendly Amenities: The kids’ menu provides excellent value at $9, including a drink, entrée, side, and cookie. The restaurant welcomes families with children and offers high chairs and accommodating service that makes dining with little ones stress-free.

Convenient Features: Free parking in their large lot eliminates one common dining hassle, while takeout options and gift cards make it easy to share the Log Cabin experience with others. The restaurant also offers catering services for special events.

Peak Hours Strategy: Weekend mornings and Friday fish fry nights tend to be busiest, but the efficient service typically keeps wait times manageable. Weekday visits often provide a more relaxed pace for those who prefer quieter dining experiences.

Takeaway Options: Many guests leave with fresh loaves of bread, whole pies, or slices to enjoy later. The on-site bakery makes it easy to extend your Log Cabin experience beyond your meal, and these items make excellent gifts for friends and family.

You Can Find Everything From Genuine Military Helmets To Squirrel Underpants At This Milwaukee Store

More in Wisconsin

You Can Find Everything From Genuine Military Helmets To Squirrel Underpants At This Milwaukee Store

Discover More

Log Cabin Family Restaurant
📍 1215 8th St, Baraboo, WI 53913

Writer: Alicia Verville
Contributor

I love writing and I love Minneapolis! My favorite places to explore are charming small towns, vibrant arts scene, and hidden gems anywhere outdoors. Fall foliage with a good documentary is my version of heaven.