Posted in

See Why Maple Bacon And Puppy Chow Rice Crispie Treats Are Taking West Allis By Storm

What began as one woman’s passionate sweet tooth has blossomed into Wisconsin’s most creative dessert destination.

Carrie’s Crispies started in 2015 when Carrie took her passion for Rice Crispie Treats and turned it into the first dedicated Rice Crispie Treat Company in the Midwest. This isn’t your typical childhood snack – each treat represents a gourmet twist on a beloved classic.

You’ll find this charming West Allis shop transforming the humble rice crispy treat into sophisticated confections that surprise and delight.

With over 40 creative flavors rotating through their menu, the shop offers an impressive range of options that go far beyond traditional expectations.

The variety spans from familiar comfort flavors to adventurous seasonal creations.

Get Up Close With Black Bears & Birds Of Prey At This Fun-Yet-Educational Zoo In Chippewa Falls Related

More in Wisconsin

Get Up Close With Black Bears & Birds Of Prey At This Fun-Yet-Educational Zoo In Chippewa Falls

Keep Exploring →

Flavor Adventures Worth Taking

Birthday Cake Celebration: This festive flavor captures all the joy of a birthday party in crispy form. Sweet vanilla notes blend with colorful sprinkles and that signature chewy texture, delivering celebration vibes without the need for actual cake or candles.

Maple Bacon Mastery: The combination of sweet maple and savory bacon creates an unexpectedly harmonious flavor profile. The smoky bacon elements provide a delightful contrast to the rich maple sweetness, making this an adventurous choice that pays off beautifully.

Fruity Cereal Nostalgia: The fruity pebbles variety brings childhood breakfast memories to life. The colorful cereal pieces add both visual appeal and that distinctive fruity flavor that balances sweetness with playful nostalgia.

Seasonal Specialties: Summer brings tropical-inspired options like pineapple mai tai and strawberry margarita, while other seasons feature unique offerings like root beer float. These rotating selections ensure repeat visits always offer something new to discover.

Classic Comfort Combinations: Rocky Road delivers the perfect blend of chocolate, marshmallow, and nuts in every bite. Peanut Butter Cup offers rich, creamy peanut butter with chocolate accents, while Birthday Cake remains a consistently popular choice for good reason.

Taste The Secret Spice Blend On 900 Pounds Of Prime Rib Made Weekly At This Iconic Wisconsin Supper Club

More in Wisconsin

Taste The Secret Spice Blend On 900 Pounds Of Prime Rib Made Weekly At This Iconic Wisconsin Supper Club

Discover More

Puppy Chow Paradise: This creative interpretation of the beloved party snack combines chocolate, peanut butter, and powdered sugar elements in crispy treat form, offering familiar flavors in an entirely new format.

Sweet Shop Atmosphere

Intimate Shopping Experience: The compact retail space creates a cozy browsing environment where you can easily survey the full range of available flavors. The small size adds to the boutique feel rather than overwhelming you with choices.

Colorful Presentation: Bright displays showcase the various treats like edible artwork, making the selection process visually engaging. Each flavor’s unique appearance helps guide your choices while adding to the shop’s cheerful ambiance.

Personal Touch: The family-owned nature of the business shines through in the welcoming atmosphere. You’ll experience genuine enthusiasm for the products and the craft behind creating each unique flavor combination.

Other Considerations

Value Proposition: The generous double-decker size justifies the pricing, especially when you factor in the gourmet quality and creative flavors. Bundle deals like four treats for $15 provide additional savings, while discounted “scraps” offer budget-friendly options at just one dollar.

Since 1945 This Kenosha Drive-In Has Served Root Beer Floats, Roller Skates, And The Burger Of Your Dreams Related

More in Wisconsin

Since 1945 This Kenosha Drive-In Has Served Root Beer Floats, Roller Skates, And The Burger Of Your Dreams

Keep Exploring →

Dietary Inclusivity: The majority of flavors accommodate gluten-free diets, with clear labeling to help you identify suitable options. Some varieties also meet dairy-free requirements, ensuring most dietary restrictions can be accommodated.

Gifting Potential: The treats work wonderfully as corporate gifts, party favors, or personal presents. Custom labeling options for special occasions add a personalized touch that elevates simple treats into memorable gifts.

Rewards Program: A free loyalty club offers points toward future purchases and keeps you informed about new flavor launches and promotional events. This program rewards frequent visitors while building community around the brand.

Operating Schedule: Limited hours require planning your visit carefully. The shop operates Wednesday through Saturday only, with shorter Saturday hours ending at 3:00 pm. Weekend visits need particular timing awareness.

Sampling Strategy: Mini-sized versions allow you to explore multiple flavors without overcommitting. This approach works perfectly for first-time visitors wanting to discover their preferences across the extensive flavor range.

Experience The Amazing Arctic Passage Exhibit At Henry Vilas Zoo, Madison’s Premier Free Wildlife Destination

More in Wisconsin

Experience The Amazing Arctic Passage Exhibit At Henry Vilas Zoo, Madison’s Premier Free Wildlife Destination

Discover More

Carrie’s Crispies
📍 7133 W Becher St, West Allis, WI 53219

Writer: Alicia Verville
Click to read bio

I love writing and I love Minneapolis! My favorite places to explore are charming small towns, vibrant arts scene, and hidden gems anywhere outdoors. Fall foliage with a good documentary is my version of heaven.