- Attraction: Slice of Chicago
- Location: 507 W Wisconsin St, Sparta, WI 54656
- Industry: Restaurant
- Website: https://www.spsliceofchicago.com/
What happens when a converted house becomes home to the most authentic Chicago-style pizza experience outside of Illinois?
You discover that some of Wisconsin’s greatest culinary treasures hide in the most unexpected places.
Since opening its doors in 2011, Slice of Chicago has transformed from a local secret into Monroe County’s pizza destination, drawing visitors from across the Midwest who refuse to settle for chain restaurant mediocrity.
Located in a charming converted house on West Wisconsin Street, this family-owned pizzeria creates an atmosphere that feels like dining in someone’s cozy living room – if that living room happened to serve the most incredible deep-dish pizza you’ve ever tasted.
The intimate setting accommodates just enough guests to maintain that special neighborhood feel, while the military-themed décor pays tribute to America’s servicemen and women.
Related
More in Wisconsin
The Big Cow Named Bernice Is Your Gateway To The Most Delicious Ice Cream You’ll Ever Taste At This Manitowoc Gem
Keep Exploring →Pizza Perfection Worth The Drive
The Gut Buster Deep Dish: This signature creation lives up to its intimidating name with layers of premium toppings piled high on thick, perfectly seasoned crust. You’ll find yourself struggling to finish even two slices of this hearty masterpiece, but every bite delivers that authentic Chicago experience that keeps customers driving from neighboring counties.
Hand-Tossed Thin Crust: Don’t overlook this lighter option that showcases the restaurant’s versatility. The thin crust achieves the perfect balance of crispy exterior and tender center, while generous cheese coverage ensures you get exactly what you pay for when requesting extra toppings.
Belly Buster Thin Crust: A local favorite that combines the best of both worlds – substantial enough to satisfy hearty appetites while maintaining that signature thin-crust snap. The careful slicing into smaller pieces makes it easier to enjoy without the usual pizza grease disasters.
Deep Pan Innovation: Unlike traditional Chicago deep-dish, Slice of Chicago creates their own unique style with thick, doughy edges surrounding a thinner center. This distinctive approach provides satisfying crust without overwhelming the carefully balanced cheese-to-sauce ratio that keeps customers coming back.
Premium Ingredients: Every pizza features homemade dough prepared fresh daily, vegetables sliced that morning, finest cured cheeses, and zesty tomato sauces that strike the perfect balance between spice and tang. The quality difference becomes immediately apparent with that first bite.
More in Wisconsin
This 130-Year-Old Chocolate Shop In Oshkosh Creates The World’s Best Hand-Dipped Sweets
Discover MoreBeyond Pizza Excellence
Garlic Cheese Bread: This appetizer deserves its own spotlight, featuring perfectly golden bread with a crispy exterior that gives way to melted cheese heaven. Add any topping for just fifty cents to create your own custom starter.
Italian Beef Sandwiches: Seasoned with special spices and sliced thin, these juicy sandwiches on Italian rolls provide a taste of Chicago’s street food culture right in small-town Wisconsin.
Meatball Sandwiches: Customers consistently rate these as the best in the area, featuring tender meatballs that complement the restaurant’s homemade marinara sauce perfectly.
BBQ Wings: Cooked fresh in-house with honey BBQ seasoning that adds the right touch of sweetness without overwhelming the crispy chicken.
Mac and Cheese: Showcasing Wisconsin’s cheese heritage, this creamy side dish delivers all the cheesy goodness you’d expect from America’s Dairyland.
Related
More in Wisconsin
This Colgate Sculpture Garden Is Where A Carpenter With Welding Skills Created A Wonderland From Scrap Metal
Keep Exploring →Cozy House Atmosphere
Converted Home Setting: The restaurant’s unique location in a former residence creates an intimate dining experience that feels worlds away from typical pizza chains. The small dining room encourages conversation while maintaining a relaxed, family-friendly environment.
Military Tribute Décor: Thoughtful decorations honor American military personnel, creating a patriotic atmosphere that resonates with locals and visitors alike. The tasteful theme adds character without overwhelming the cozy dining space.
Intimate Seating: The compact layout means you’ll want to call ahead for groups larger than six, but this limitation actually enhances the personal service and attention to detail that makes each visit special.
Home-Style Comfort: Everything from the lighting to the table arrangements reinforces that “dining at a friend’s house” feeling that transforms a simple pizza dinner into a memorable experience.
Other Considerations
Fair Pricing: Expect mid-tier pricing that reflects the quality ingredients and generous portions. Most customers find the value exceptional compared to chain alternatives, especially considering the premium ingredients and authentic preparation methods.
More in Wisconsin
Discover The Netherlands In Wisconsin: The Little Chute Windmill Is A Fully-Functioning Dutch Masterpiece
Discover MoreLimited Hours: Open Wednesday through Sunday with afternoon and evening service, so plan accordingly. The focused schedule allows the owners to maintain consistent quality while providing work-life balance.
Parking Convenience: The residential location provides easier parking than typical downtown restaurants, with both street parking and nearby spaces readily available.
Family-Friendly Environment: Children receive special attention, including complimentary pizza dough to play with while waiting – a thoughtful touch that keeps young diners entertained.
Takeout Excellence: The pizza travels exceptionally well for those preferring to enjoy their meal elsewhere, maintaining quality and temperature during transport.
Call Ahead Recommended: Popular dinner hours can get busy, so calling ahead ensures your table is ready and reduces wait times, especially on weekends.
Related
More in Wisconsin
Find The Best Garlic Bread And Nostalgic 1919 Root Beer To Pair With Your Pizza At Sam’s In Wausau
Keep Exploring →Slice of Chicago
📍 507 W Wisconsin St, Sparta, WI 54656
