- Attraction: Mountain Goat Market
- Location: 109 W Main St, Monteagle, TN 37356
- Industry: Restaurant
- Website: https://www.mtngoatmarket.com/
A converted 1940s Greyhound bus station housing a restaurant might sound like an odd concept, yet Mountain Goat Market proves that remarkable dining experiences can emerge from the most unexpected places.
Located in Monteagle, Tennessee, this establishment sits strategically between Nashville and Chattanooga, transforming what could be a forgettable highway pit stop into something worth planning your route around.
Opening in 2013 following extensive renovations that honored the building’s historical architecture while infusing contemporary character, this destination has earned its reputation as Monteagle’s culinary crown jewel.
Walking through the doors, you’ll encounter four distinct experiences woven seamlessly together: a counter-service deli crafting custom sandwiches, a pizza kitchen producing creative pies, an espresso station preparing specialty beverages, and a marketplace brimming with locally-sourced goods.
The guiding principle centers on utilizing fresh, regional ingredients to create what the establishment proudly brands as “Killer Eats.” Premium Boar’s Head meats form the foundation of sandwich offerings, while housemade desserts tempt passersby from their prominent display cases.
Related
More in Tennessee
Hike The Exact Spot In Lawrenceburg Where Frontier Legend Davy Crockett Built His Mills And Distillery
Keep Exploring →Standout Sandwich Selections
The Cuban: Slow-roasted pork mingles with ham, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard before being pressed until the exterior achieves that coveted golden crispness.
An unexpected touch of barbecue sauce adds depth and complexity without masking the traditional Cuban flavor profile. The result is a sandwich that honors its roots while adding a subtle Tennessee twist.
Chicken Salad on Croissant: This isn’t ordinary deli chicken salad. The housemade preparation incorporates tender chicken pieces with sweet grapes, crisp apple chunks, celery for crunch, toasted pecans, and a honey poppyseed dressing that brings harmonious sweetness.
Nestled in a flaky, buttery croissant, the generous serving often proves too substantial to finish in one sitting. The interplay between sweet and savory elements creates something genuinely special.
Goat B.L.A.T.: Think of this as the sophisticated cousin of a standard BLT. Sliced turkey serves as the primary protein, accompanied by crispy bacon strips, sharp cheddar cheese, creamy avocado slices, fresh lettuce, ripe tomato, and mayo, all layered between hearty multigrain wheat bread.
More in Tennessee
Discover A True Taste Of France With The Amazing Eclairs And Macarons At This Nashville Cafe
Discover MoreIt delivers satisfying substance while maintaining a lighter feel than traditional deli sandwiches.
Rajun Cajun: For those craving heat, this option delivers admirably. Cajun-seasoned turkey pairs with bacon, smoky chipotle Gouda, chipotle mayo, and fresh spinach on toasted sourdough.
The spice level registers as pleasantly bold without overwhelming your palate, while the melted Gouda provides creamy richness that balances the heat perfectly.
Blazin’ Club: Buffalo-style chicken forms the star here, joined by bacon, melted pepper jack cheese, crisp lettuce, tomato, and cooling mayo served on sourdough bread.
The tangy buffalo sauce provides kick while the pepper jack amplifies the heat just enough. It’s substantial without being heavy, making it ideal for fueling afternoon adventures.
Related
More in Tennessee
History Echoes Through The Trenches At Tennessee’s Fort Donelson, Where The Union Turned The Tide
Keep Exploring →Creative Pizza Offerings
Fancy Pants: Instead of traditional red sauce, this upscale creation starts with an olive oil base. Grilled chicken, mozzarella, crumbled feta, roasted red peppers, and fresh basil get finished with a balsamic glaze drizzle.
The thin crust emerges from the oven with beautiful char marks and ideal crispness. That balsamic reduction adds a sophisticated sweet-tangy dimension that elevates every bite.
Kale Yeah: Despite featuring a trendy green vegetable, this pesto-based pizza wins over even the kale-averse. Italian sausage, kale, tangy goat cheese, and mozzarella combine to create unexpectedly robust flavors.
The herbaceous pesto provides aromatic richness, the sausage adds savory meatiness, and the goat cheese contributes creamy tanginess that unifies the toppings beautifully.
Pickle Pie: Pickles on pizza might sound unconventional, but this combination absolutely succeeds. Starting with red sauce, the pizza gets topped with cheddar, seasoned ground beef, bacon, onions, and dill pickle chips for a flavor profile reminiscent of a great cheeseburger.
More in Tennessee
This Intimate Nashville Museum Preserves The Untold History Of Black Music That Shook Music City
Discover MoreThe pickles retain their satisfying crunch while providing bright acidity that cuts through the richness masterfully.
Classic Margherita: Sometimes simplicity triumphs. Fresh mozzarella, sliced tomatoes, and torn basil leaves atop red sauce showcase ingredient quality without unnecessary embellishment. The thin crust allows each component to shine, delivering fresh, vibrant flavors rather than heavy, greasy pizza.
Fresh Salads & Wraps
Killer Kale Salad: Tender kale forms the foundation, tossed with plump blueberries, shredded carrots, sliced almonds, crumbled goat cheese, and dried cranberries, all coated in a blueberry pomegranate vinaigrette.
The fruit components provide natural sweetness, the goat cheese adds pleasant tang, and the almonds deliver satisfying texture contrast. Expect impressively large portions.
Strawberry Spinach: Baby spinach gets combined with fresh strawberry slices, crunchy walnuts, thinly sliced red onion, and goat cheese crumbles, dressed with white balsamic vinaigrette.
Related
More in Tennessee
You Can Meet Fascinating Zebra-Donkey Hybrids And Towering Camels At This Sevierville Farm
Keep Exploring →The composition feels refreshing yet filling, perfect for warmer weather or when you want something lighter before indulging in dessert.
Wrapped Creations: The Fiesta Burrito wraps chipotle chicken, corn and black bean salsa, lettuce, tomato, and avocado lime ranch into a portable meal.
Meanwhile, the Caesar Wrap transforms the classic salad into handheld form with chicken, mozzarella, shaved parmesan, tomatoes, and spinach bound together with Caesar dressing.
Irresistible Dessert Selection
The Sweet Display: An expansive windowed cooler showcases an impressive array of housemade desserts stretching roughly thirty feet.
The coconut lemon cake balances tropical coconut flavor with bright citrus notes perfectly. Turtle cheesecake layers chocolate, caramel, and pecans for decadent indulgence. The triple chocolate cake delivers deep cocoa satisfaction and comes available in gluten-free versions.
Creative Confections: The Butter Monkey takes sliced bananas, chocolate chips, and peanut butter, grilling everything together inside a flour tortilla for a warm, melty handheld dessert. Monster cookie bars offer thick, chewy satisfaction.
Butterfinger cake appeals to candy bar enthusiasts. Fresh cannoli brings Italian bakery quality to this Tennessee mountain town. The oatmeal creme pie and blueberry crumble provide comforting, homestyle options.
Frozen Treats: Hand-dipped ice cream, thick milkshakes, and ice cream sandwiches round out the sweet offerings. Wine slushies provide a fun option for adults seeking refreshment.
The espresso bar produces specialty coffee drinks that pair wonderfully with anything from the dessert case, from cappuccinos to flavored lattes.
Atmosphere & Character
Vibrant & Artistic: Eye-catching murals cover interior walls and extend into the parking lot, creating a playful, artistic atmosphere throughout the space.
The decor embraces a colorful, casual aesthetic with whimsical goat-themed artwork scattered about. High-top tables fashioned from repurposed industrial wire spools add industrial charm, while the overall ambiance stays approachable and relaxed rather than trying too hard.
Historic Foundation, Contemporary Spirit: The 2013 renovation preserved the building’s architectural heritage while modernizing the space for today’s diners.
You can still sense echoes of the structure’s bus station past, though now it buzzes with the lively energy of a thriving local hotspot. The atmosphere maintains comfortable casualness whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or lingering with companions.
Seating Options: Generous indoor seating accommodates crowds even during busy periods, though arriving before the noon rush helps secure prime spots.
An appealing outdoor patio area welcomes guests in pleasant weather and accepts well-behaved dogs for those traveling with pets. The interior feels surprisingly spacious rather than cramped, with good traffic flow despite the building’s compact footprint.
The Marketplace Experience: Adjacent to the dining area, the retail section stocks eclectic local goods including handcrafted goat’s milk soaps, aromatic soy candles, hand-sewn textiles from African artisans, local honey and preserves, unique gift items, and Mountain Goat Market branded merchandise.
Browsing the shop while waiting for your order or after eating provides added entertainment and excellent souvenir options.
Practical Information
Budget Expectations: Sandwiches typically range from eight to twelve dollars, while pizzas span ten to eighteen dollars depending on size selection. Individual dessert slices generally cost three to four dollars.
The pricing falls comfortably in the affordable-to-moderate category, particularly considering the generous portions and quality ingredients. When sandwiches prove too large to finish and desserts could easily serve two, the value proposition becomes quite strong.
Ordering Process: You’ll place orders at the counter where a colorful chalkboard displays menu options, receive a number, then select a table while the kitchen prepares your food.
Despite frequently having lines extending outside, the kitchen operates efficiently and turnover stays surprisingly quick. Pizzas often emerge in roughly ten minutes even during peak periods.
Dietary Flexibility: Mountain Goat Market accommodates various dietary requirements admirably. Any sandwich can be prepared on gluten-free bread, and cauliflower crust provides another gluten-free pizza option.
The kitchen wraps gluten-free bread in foil when grilling to minimize cross-contamination concerns. Multiple vegetarian and vegan choices exist throughout the menu, and the robust salad selection offers fresh, lighter alternatives.
Access & Convenience: An ample parking lot eliminates typical small-town parking frustrations.
The location directly off Interstate 24 at exit 134 makes Mountain Goat Market exceptionally convenient for highway travelers, yet it maintains genuine local charm rather than feeling like a manufactured tourist stop.
Both Monteagle residents and passing visitors genuinely embrace this establishment.
Family Considerations: Children will find plenty of appealing options, from straightforward grilled cheese and peanut butter and jelly to customizable pizzas.
The laid-back atmosphere tolerates energetic kids comfortably, and the gift shop provides distraction while awaiting food. Booster chairs are available for younger diners needing extra height.
Operating Schedule: The market opens Tuesday through Saturday from 11am to 6pm, remaining closed Sundays and Mondays.
This limited schedule can surprise unprepared travelers, so plan your visit accordingly. Peak lunch crowds typically occur between noon and 2pm, making slightly earlier or later arrival times strategic for shorter waits.
Road Trip Essential: Positioned nearly equidistant between Nashville and Chattanooga along I-24, Mountain Goat Market has become legendary among frequent interstate travelers.
It provides substantial enough fuel for several more hours behind the wheel, delivers memorable enough flavors to warrant the brief detour, and creates experiences that have you planning future trips specifically to stop here again.
Mountain Goat Market
📍 109 W Main St, Monteagle, TN 37356
