- Attraction: Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
- Location: 5400 Kingston Pike, Knoxville, TN 37919
- Industry: Bakery
- Website: https://buttermilkskypie.com/locations/bearden/
At Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Knoxville you’ll find plenty to satisfy a sweet tooth.
It’s a place where every handmade creation tells a story of Southern tradition and family love.
Founded by Scott and Meredith Layton in 2012, this charming spot on Kingston Pike traces its roots to two spirited grandmothers from Arkansas and Mississippi—Ruth and Edith—whose recipes form the foundation of everything baked here.
The shop has since become a beloved East Tennessee institution, earning praise from locals and visitors alike who can’t resist the scratch-made goodness churned out daily.
Signature Pies You Can’t Miss
The I-40 Pie: This bestseller has a backstory as delicious as its filling. Named during a traffic jam between Knoxville and Memphis, this creation layers toasted pecans, chocolate chips, and coconut into a buttery shortbread crust.
Related
More in Tennessee
The Flaky Croissants And Brown Butter Beignets At This Nashville Bakery Are Well Worth The Wait
Keep Exploring →It’s become such a phenomenon that people across multiple states now consider it their go-to order. The combination hits all the right notes—nutty, sweet, chocolatey, with just enough texture contrast to keep things interesting.
Chocolate Chip Cookie Pie: Imagine your favorite warm, gooey chocolate chip cookie transformed into pie form. That’s what you’ll find here.
Brown sugar, butter, vanilla, and plenty of chocolate chips get baked into a shortbread crust, creating something that feels nostalgic and indulgent all at once. It’s the kind of dessert that makes you want to grab a fork and forget about sharing.
Key Lime Perfection: The graham cracker crust holds a balanced key lime filling that avoids that sharp, sour aftertaste some versions have.
Instead, you’ll taste perfectly tangy citrus topped with whipped cream cheese and finished with a sweet key lime glaze and graham cracker crumbles. It’s refreshing without being overpowering.
More in Tennessee
This West Tennessee Adventure Puts You Eye-To-Eye With Camels And Bison From Your Car Window
Discover MoreCoconut Cream Classic: This Southern staple features slow-cooked coconut filling crowned with Italian meringue that resembles fluffy marshmallow. The stovetop preparation gives it a rich, sweet flavor that tastes authentically homemade.
Peanut Butter Dream: Set in an Oreo cookie crust, this pie combines whipped peanut butter and cream cheese filling, then gets topped with house-made chocolate ganache, more whipped cream cheese, and a sprinkle of Reese’s crumble. It’s decadent in the best way possible.
Pecan and Buttermilk Varieties: The traditional pecan pie delivers gooey filling wrapped in that signature buttery shortbread crust, while the buttermilk pie offers something smoother and milder—like a cross between chess pie and custard.
Size Options & Special Treats
Multiple Sizes Available: You’ll find pies in adorable 4-inch personal sizes perfect for solo indulgence, standard 9-inch pies ideal for sharing, and even tiny 2-inch party pies that make great sampler options or event treats.
Cloud 9 Experience: Want to elevate your pie game?
Related
More in Tennessee
This Coffee Shop In Gatlinburg Serves Art, Herbal Teas, And The Smokies’ Tastiest Muffins
Keep Exploring →Order a Cloud 9, which gently mixes a mini pie with a generous scoop of locally-made ice cream. The result is a dreamy swirl where crust, filling, and ice cream blend together in each spoonful. It’s like pie à la mode, only exponentially better.
Seasonal Surprises: While six classic flavors remain available year-round, the shop rotates two seasonal options and features a monthly special. Past favorites have included cherry, strawberry, pumpkin spice, and lemon icebox varieties.
Shopping Experience & Details
Takeout Focus: This isn’t a dine-in establishment—it’s purely takeout, so plan to enjoy your pie elsewhere. The parking lot works in a pinch if you can’t wait to dig in.
Fresh Daily Baking: Everything gets made from scratch each day using those time-honored family recipes and traditional methods that set these pies apart from mass-produced alternatives.
Pie it Forward Program: Each month, the shop selects a specialty pie flavor and donates a portion of proceeds to local charities and nonprofits, allowing you to support your community while satisfying your sweet tooth.
More in Tennessee
This Coffee Shop In Gatlinburg Serves Art, Herbal Teas, And The Smokies’ Tastiest Muffins
Discover MorePricing & Planning
Investment Worth Making: Full-sized pies typically run around $28-30, which sits on the higher end compared to grocery store options.
The 4-inch personal pies offer a more budget-friendly entry point. While the pricing might give some pause, you’re paying for quality ingredients, handmade preparation, and recipes that took generations to perfect. Most find the richness and flavor justify the cost.
Pre-ordering Recommended: Especially during holidays or weekends, calling ahead ensures you snag your favorite flavors. The shop offers delivery through major platforms, but picking up directly guarantees the freshest experience.
Pie Perks Program: Sign up for their birthday club and you’ll receive a free 4-inch pie on your special day with purchase—a sweet deal that encourages repeat visits.
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop
📍 5400 Kingston Pike, Knoxville, TN 37919
Related
