Circles on the Square - Medina, OH

Attraction: Circles on the Square
Location: 28 Public Square, Medina, OH 44256
Industry: Donut Shop
Website: https://www.circlesonthesquare.net/

Right here in Ohio’s charming historic Medina Square sits a donut revolution where tradition meets innovation in the most delicious way possible.

Circles on the Square opened on September 17, 2017, bringing Medina’s first gourmet donut shop to the heart of this picturesque downtown.

Unlike typical donut shops with stale display cases, every single donut here gets handcrafted right in front of you the moment you order it.

Co-owner Scott Sandusky describes it perfectly: “It’s like Chipotle for donuts!”

This family-owned gem has already earned serious recognition, winning the Cleveland Donut Fest in both 2018 and 2020 with their raspberry cookie donut – a flavor combination that’s as unique as it sounds incredible.

Made-to-Order Donut Magic

The Fresh Factor: You’ll witness something special the moment you step inside – donuts being crafted from scratch right before your eyes. Each donut is handcrafted in front of guests once ordered, and they never sit in a display case. The warm, just-made donuts you’ll receive are a world away from anything you’ve experienced at chain shops.

Award-Winning Flavors: The raspberry cookie donut that won them Cleveland Donut Fest recognition twice represents just how creative this place gets. You’ll discover combinations like the Buckeye (chocolate and peanut butter that’s “so deliciously ooey gooey”) and the Maple Bacon that’s “an explosion in your mouth!”

Classic Perfection: Traditional favorites include plain, cinnamon sugar, vanilla glazed, chocolate glazed, and glazed with sprinkles. But don’t let “traditional” fool you – when made fresh to order, even a simple vanilla glazed becomes something extraordinary. The donuts themselves are described as “the most perfect moist cake” with perfectly balanced toppings that aren’t overly rich.

Gourmet Adventures: The shop offers about 70 different flavors including seasonal rotating selections. Popular choices include Raspberry Strudel, Monster Cookie Dough, and Chocolate Chip, while standouts like Black Forest and stuffed French toast showcase their creative range. Seasonal options like Strawberry Crunch Donut and Oatmeal Cream Pie Donut keep the menu exciting year-round.

The Mini Revolution: These are “miniature donuts that are amazing” – smaller than traditional donuts but packed with flavor. You can easily try two or three different flavors in one visit, making it perfect for sampling their incredible variety.

This Expansive Cleveland Metroparks Gem Offers Miles Of Trails And Green Space For All

Discover More

Historic Square Charm & Atmosphere

Prime Location: Everything’s located on the Medina square within walking distance of other fun little places to shop, eat, and grab coffee. The historic setting adds character to your donut experience, making it feel like a special destination rather than just another food stop.

Cozy Interior: The shop features a quaint eating area looking out to Medina Square, creating a perfect spot to enjoy your fresh donuts while watching the charming town square activity. The intimate space encourages you to savor the moment and the incredible flavors.

Visual Menu Experience: When you enter, you’ll be warmly greeted and introduced to their visual menu, making it easy to see exactly what each donut creation looks like before ordering. This adds to the excitement of choosing your perfect combination.

Made While You Watch: You can watch them make your donuts while you wait, turning your visit into entertainment. Many customers enjoy receiving warm donuts fresh from preparation, creating an experience you simply can’t get elsewhere.

Other Considerations

Reasonable Pricing: Prices range from $1.25 for classic flavors like plain and cinnamon sugar to $1.75 for gourmet creations like Maple Bacon and Buckeye. Multiple reviewers note that “the price wasn’t bad either”, especially considering the made-to-order quality and unique flavors you’re getting.

Value for Quality: Customers don’t mind “paying a higher price for quality products” because the freshness and craftsmanship justify the cost. The “reasonable prices and high-quality donuts” create excellent value compared to mass-produced alternatives.

Convenient Parking: There’s free parking around the square where the shop is located, making it easy to stop by without worrying about parking fees or availability.

Limited Hours: They’re open Tuesday through Friday 7:00 AM – 2:00 PM, Saturday 8:00 AM – 2:00 PM, and Sunday 9:00 AM – 2:00 PM (closed Mondays). While the limited hours may pose a challenge for some, arriving early ensures the best selection and guarantees you’ll experience the magic of watching your donuts being made fresh.

Perfect for Groups: The shop offers catering services for birthday parties and other large events, and you can easily order a dozen donuts to share. As one reviewer noted: “Get one or a dozen (although one is never enough)”.

Circles on the Square
📍 28 Public Square, Medina, OH 44256