- Attraction: The Top Steakhouse
- Location: 2891 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209
- Industry: Steakhouse
- Website: https://thetopsteakhouse.com/
Forget everything you think you know about steakhouses because The Top Steakhouse operates on an entirely different wavelength.
Since 1955, this Columbus institution has perfected the art of transporting diners straight into a scene from Mad Men, complete with gin martinis that could fuel a three-hour business meeting and steaks so substantial they’d make Don Draper weep with joy.
Walking through those doors feels like stepping through a portal to when cocktails were stronger, portions were bigger, and atmosphere mattered more than Instagram-worthy plating.
You’ll immediately notice the leather banquettes that have hosted decades of Columbus power lunches and anniversary dinners, while the piano bar continues to draw crowds who appreciate live entertainment with their prime rib.
Signature Steaks & Standout Dishes
The Prime Rib: You’ll discover why locals have declared this the best prime rib in town. Cooked low and slow, each slice arrives perfectly pink with a gorgeous herb crust that adds just the right amount of savory punch. The au jus flows like liquid gold, and you’ll find yourself soaking up every drop with those complimentary dinner rolls.
Related
More in Ohio
This Ohio Restaurant Is A Must-Visit For Hearty Dishes And A Distinctive Atmosphere
Keep Exploring →French Onion Soup: This isn’t your average starter. The broth delivers an incredibly rich beef base that tastes like it’s been simmering for hours, topped with properly melted cheese that stretches from bowl to spoon in the most satisfying way possible.
Strip Steaks: These arrive exactly as ordered, with that perfect char on the outside and tender pink interior that serious steak lovers demand. The seasoning keeps it simple but effective, letting the quality of the beef shine through without unnecessary fuss.
Oysters Rockefeller: A surprisingly delicious appetizer that showcases the kitchen’s range beyond beef. The spinach mixture is creamy and flavorful, with each oyster cooked to silky perfection.
The Cocktails: Those gin martinis aren’t just drinks – they’re liquid time machines. Perfectly balanced, ice-cold, and strong enough to remind you why the three-martini lunch was once a thing.
Atmosphere & Décor
The Mad Men Vibe: You’ll feel like Frank Sinatra might walk through the door at any moment. The dark, intimate lighting creates an old-school masculine atmosphere that’s become increasingly rare in today’s restaurant scene. Leather everywhere, dim lighting, and that unmistakable feeling that important conversations happen here.
More in Ohio
Your New Favorite Ice Cream Is Waiting For You At This Beloved Yellow Springs Farm
Discover MoreThe Piano Bar: Live music happens nightly, featuring talented musicians who understand that dinner entertainment should enhance conversation, not overpower it. You can take your wine over and enjoy performances that range from jazz standards to contemporary favorites.
The Lighting: Yes, it’s dark – some say almost spooky dark. This isn’t a place for reading fine print or taking food photos. Instead, it’s designed for intimate conversations and focusing on the company across the table rather than distractions around the room.
Private Dining: The intimate private rooms work beautifully for celebrations or business dinners where you want to feel like you’ve been given the VIP treatment.
Other Considerations
Pricing Expectations: You’re looking at upscale steakhouse pricing that reflects both the quality of ingredients and the decades of reputation. The portions are generous enough that many diners take home leftovers, making the value proposition more reasonable than it initially appears.
Parking Situation: Free parking is available in their lot, which eliminates the downtown hassle of hunting for street spots or paying garage fees.
Related
More in Ohio
The Ohio Water Park Where Natural Terrain Creates Slides So Intense They Rival Major Theme Parks
Keep Exploring →Dress Code Flexibility: While you’ll see everything from business casual to full suits, the atmosphere welcomes both celebration dinners and more relaxed occasions. No jacket required, but you’ll want to dress up a bit to match the sophisticated vibe.
Reservation Strategy: This isn’t a walk-in kind of place, especially on weekends. The popularity means booking ahead ensures you get that table in the main dining room rather than being squeezed into less desirable seating.
Family Friendliness: While kids are welcome, this definitely skews toward adults who appreciate the throwback atmosphere and aren’t looking for a quick, casual meal.
The Top Steakhouse
📍 2891 E Main St, Columbus, OH 43209
