- Attraction: Millburn Deli
- Location: 328 Millburn Ave, Millburn, NJ 07041
- Industry: Deli
- Website: https://www.millburndeli.com/
Picture walking into a deli where a model airplane dangles from the ceiling, vintage signs cover every inch of wall space, and someone behind the counter honks a bike horn before the entire crew shouts your sandwich order in unison.
This isn’t just any sandwich shop—it’s a theatrical experience wrapped in wax paper. Family-owned since opening day in 1946, Millburn Deli has transformed the simple act of ordering lunch into a quirky ritual that keeps locals coming back decade after decade.
The menu stretches across the back wall like a kaleidoscope of possibilities, offering everything from classic deli fare to inventive pressed creations that have earned national recognition.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or settling in at their outdoor tables, this Millburn institution proves that great sandwiches are worth the wait—and the lines that often snake out the door prove everyone else agrees.
Signature Sandwiches Worth the Hype
The Sloppy Joe: Forget everything you think you know about sloppy joes. This is the New Jersey version—a triple-decker masterpiece on rye bread stacked with your choice of deli meat, Swiss cheese, tangy coleslaw, and Russian dressing.
Related
More in New Jersey
From Fermented Chilis To Vegan Cheese, Talula’s Is The Asbury Park Restaurant Reinventing Sit-Down Meals
Keep Exploring →The sandwich is cut into three distinctive diagonal sections, creating that iconic middle triangle piece that locals debate whether to save for last or devour first. Each bite delivers a perfect balance of creamy coleslaw, savory meat, and that signature Russian dressing that ties it all together. The rye bread holds up beautifully against all that moisture, though you’ll definitely want extra napkins.
The Godfadda: Frequently cited as the most popular sandwich on the menu, this pressed masterpiece features a golden-fried chicken cutlet layered with crispy bacon, fresh mozzarella, and Russian dressing on a sub roll.
When pressed, the bread gets delightfully crispy while the cheese melts into every crevice. The bacon adds a salty punch that complements the creamy elements perfectly. It’s rich, it’s indulgent, and it’s easy to see why this sandwich has been called one of the best in New Jersey.
The Gobbler: Available year-round, this Thanksgiving-inspired creation transforms holiday flavors into sandwich form. Freshly sliced roast turkey gets topped with homemade stuffing, chunky cranberry sauce, crisp lettuce, mayo, and black pepper—all nestled between soft rye bread.
When you order it, prepare for the show: a vintage bike horn honks and everyone behind the counter shouts “Goooblerrr!” in perfect unison. The tender turkey paired with tart cranberries and flavorful stuffing creates that nostalgic holiday taste in every bite.
More in New Jersey
You Can See World-Class DJs And Chart-Topping Stars At This Hidden New Jersey Nightlife Gem
Discover MoreChicken Cutlet Creations: Beyond the Godfadda, you’ll find an entire lineup of chicken cutlet sandwiches. The Buffalo Big Bird brings heat with bleu cheese, buffalo sauce, lettuce, tomato, and red onion on a toasted sub.
The Jay Ray combines chicken cutlet with bacon, cheddar, BBQ sauce, and chipotle ranch on a pressed roll. Each sandwich showcases that perfectly breaded cutlet as its foundation.
Build Your Own: With an extensive selection of breads (from focaccia to baguettes), meats, cheeses, and house-made dressings, you can craft your perfect sandwich. The staff embraces creativity—nothing is too crazy to try.
Beverages & Sides
House-Made Iced Tea: Perhaps the most raved-about item after the sandwiches themselves, the homemade iced tea comes sweetened or unsweetened and perfectly complements any meal. The tea is brewed fresh daily and many regulars won’t leave without ordering a half-gallon to take home.
House Pickles: Every sandwich comes with a garlic pickle chip, but once you taste these tangy, perfectly brined pickles, you’ll want to order a full side. The garlic adds an extra kick that makes them stand out from typical deli pickles.
Related
More in New Jersey
Find Out Why This Coffee Shop In A Converted Bank Was Voted Morris County’s Best Caffeine Destination
Keep Exploring →Fresh Salads: The bowtie pasta salad deserves special mention for its house-made quality. The macaroni salad features a unique twist, and the coleslaw that goes into the sloppy joes is brined for three days before being dressed with extra-heavy mayo for maximum creaminess.
Atmosphere & Vibe
Visual Overload in the Best Way: The moment you step inside, your eyes don’t know where to look first. Colorful hand-written menu boards compete for attention with vintage signs, wicker baskets overflowing with chips, quirky figurines, and that eye-catching model airplane suspended from the ceiling. It’s kitschy, it’s chaotic, and it’s absolutely charming.
The Ordering Process: The deli operates on a number system—grab your ticket as soon as you walk in. Despite the crowds, the efficient crew keeps things moving quickly. The ordering area feels compact and buzzing with energy, while a separate adjacent building offers comfortable indoor seating for those who want to dine in.
Outdoor Dining: When weather permits, outdoor tables along Millburn Avenue provide a pleasant spot to enjoy your meal. It’s especially nice on sunny days when you can watch the downtown foot traffic go by.
Nearby Taylor Park: Just a short walk away, this public park makes the perfect picnic destination if you want to take your sandwiches to go and enjoy them surrounded by greenery.
More in New Jersey
Don’t Miss The Adorable Moo Moo Cho Choo Train And Tractor Tours Around This Charming Boonton Farm
Discover MorePlanning Your Visit
Portion Sizes & Value: These are seriously substantial sandwiches. Each one is hefty enough that you might struggle to finish it in one sitting—leftovers are common.
While prices sit in the moderate-to-higher range for a deli (specialty sandwiches typically run $12-$15), the generous portions and quality ingredients justify the cost. You’re getting fresh-baked bread, quality meats, and house-made components that elevate these beyond your average sandwich.
Parking Considerations: Street parking along Millburn Avenue operates on meters, so come prepared with quarters or use the mobile parking app. The lot can get congested during peak lunch hours, so patience is required—or better yet, call ahead to place your order for pickup.
Best Times to Visit: Expect significant crowds during the lunch rush on weekdays. If you want to avoid the longest waits, try visiting mid-morning or mid-afternoon. Weekends can also get busy, but the crew moves things along efficiently regardless.
Multiple Locations: While the original Millburn location has the most history and atmosphere, you’ll also find Millburn Deli outposts in Morristown, Montclair, Westfield, and Bridgewater if you’re elsewhere in New Jersey.
Related
More in New Jersey
Treat Yourself To Premium Sugar-Free Chocolates And Dubai-Inspired Treats At This Unique Windsor Spot
Keep Exploring →Special Touches: The deli now offers gluten-free bread options for those with dietary restrictions, though cross-contamination protocols should be discussed when ordering. They also have an app where you can earn rewards points with every purchase.
Millburn Deli
📍 328 Millburn Ave, Millburn, NJ 07041
