- Attraction: Myrtle’s Pies
- Location: 927 N Main St, Princeton, IL 61356
- Industry: Bakery
- Website: https://www.facebook.com/MyrtlesCafeAndPie
Hidden away in the charming small town of Princeton, Illinois, Myrtle’s Pies has become something of a pilgrimage destination for dessert lovers across the Midwest.
This unassuming pie shop has earned a devoted following that drives from hours away just to sample what many consider the best homemade pies in Illinois.
What started as one man’s passion for baking has evolved into a beloved institution where every single pie is crafted from scratch daily using time-honored recipes and premium ingredients.
The magic happens under the watchful eye of owner David, who has been perfecting his pie-making craft since he was just 16 years old.
Walking into Myrtle’s feels like stepping into a warm family kitchen, where the intoxicating aroma of fresh-baked pies mingles with the cozy atmosphere of a true neighborhood gem.
Related
More in Illinois
This North Aurora Nature Center Has A Cave With Folklore, Forest Trails, And Wildlife Around Every Corner
Keep Exploring →With over two dozen varieties available daily and an extensive special-order menu, this isn’t just a bakery – it’s a testament to the artistry of traditional American baking.
Signature Pie Highlights
French Silk Perfection: The French silk pie stands as an absolute masterpiece that has visitors planning return trips before they’ve even finished their slice.
The chocolate filling achieves that perfect velvety texture with rich, deep chocolate flavor, while the crust features a delicate chocolate lining that adds an extra layer of indulgence. The combination of creamy filling and flaky, handmade crust creates pure dessert bliss.
Coconut Cream Wonder: Available with either traditional pastry crust or a cookie crust option, the coconut cream pie showcases generous layers of homemade custard topped with real whipped cream and toasted coconut. Each bite delivers the perfect balance of tropical sweetness and creamy richness that makes this pie a consistent crowd favorite.
Salted Caramel Sensation: This innovative creation perfectly balances sweet and salty elements, creating an addictive flavor profile that has become a modern classic.
More in Illinois
Chicago’s Most Legendary Cheesecake Is Hiding In A Factory With Slices So Creamy You’ll Dream About Them
Discover MoreThe salted caramel filling is smooth and luxurious, offering just enough salt to enhance the caramel’s depth without overwhelming the sweetness.
Fruit Pie Excellence: The seasonal fruit pies showcase fresh, local ingredients with an ideal fruit-to-pastry ratio. Whether you choose Dutch apple with its golden streusel topping, fresh strawberry rhubarb, or the beloved peach cobbler style, each fruit pie bursts with natural flavors that aren’t overly sweetened, allowing the fruit’s character to shine through.
German Chocolate Decadence: This rich creation layers creamy chocolate custard with coconut and pecans, all nestled in that signature handmade crust.
The combination of textures and flavors creates a dessert experience that’s both familiar and extraordinary.
Peanut Butter Silk Indulgence: For peanut butter enthusiasts, this silk pie delivers creamy, smooth peanut butter flavor in a luxurious custard base.
Related
More in Illinois
Chef Moussa Is Peoria’s Underrated Mediterranean Spot That Nails A Flavor You Won’t Forget
Keep Exploring →The richness is perfectly balanced, creating a dessert that’s satisfying without being overwhelming.
Sweet Extras Beyond Pie
Monster Cookies: These oversized treats come in perfectly portioned two- or three-bite sizes, packed with chocolate chips, oats, and all the classic cookie ingredients you’d expect. At just $6 for a dozen, they’re an affordable way to extend your Myrtle’s experience.
Cream Cheese Cinnamon Rolls: These dessert plate-sized indulgences feature house-made cinnamon rolls topped with rich cream cheese frosting.
The combination of warm spices and tangy-sweet frosting creates what regulars describe as “naughty decadence.”
Caramel Pecan Rolls: Equally impressive in size, these sticky-sweet treats combine buttery caramel with crunchy pecans for a breakfast pastry that doubles as dessert.
More in Illinois
A Small Family-Run Spot In An Old Mall Is Quietly Serving The Boldest Italian Sandwiches In Central Illinois
Discover MoreDaily Muffins: The rotating selection of fresh muffins provides lighter options for those who want to start with something less indulgent before inevitably ordering pie.
Atmosphere & Charm
Vintage Appeal: The rustic décor creates an authentically charming atmosphere that feels like visiting a beloved relative’s kitchen.
Original touches and vintage elements throughout the space enhance the nostalgic experience without feeling forced or overly themed.
Cozy Intimacy: The small size of the establishment adds to its appeal rather than detracting from it.
The intimate setting encourages conversation and creates a sense of being part of something special rather than just another customer.
Related
More in Illinois
Inside Evanston’s Barn Steakhouse Where Rich Leather Chairs, Glowing Lights, And Perfectly Cooked Steaks Await
Keep Exploring →Homey Warmth: You’ll find the lighting and overall ambiance perfectly calibrated for relaxation.
The space invites you to slow down and savor your experience rather than rushing through a quick stop.
Aromatic Experience: The constant scent of baking pies creates an sensory experience that begins the moment you walk through the door. The sweet aromas of cinnamon, vanilla, and fresh pastry immediately signal that you’ve discovered something special.
Other Considerations
Exceptional Value: With slices priced around $3-4 and whole pies at approximately $20, you’ll find the pricing remarkably reasonable considering the quality and generous portions. The value becomes even more apparent when you factor in that every component is made from scratch using premium ingredients.
Smart Planning: Calling ahead is highly recommended, especially for whole pie orders or during busy periods. The shop operates on a “call a day in advance” system for special orders, and popular flavors can sell out, particularly on weekends.
Weekend Focus: Operating primarily Friday through Sunday allows the baker to focus on quality over quantity. This limited schedule means each pie receives the attention it deserves, but planning your visit around these days is essential.
Transportation Convenience: Located just one block from Princeton’s Amtrak station, the shop is surprisingly accessible for those traveling by train.
For drivers, parking is generally available without the stress found in larger cities.
Family-Friendly Appeal: The welcoming atmosphere and generous portion sizes make this an ideal stop for families, though the intimate space works equally well for romantic outings or solo indulgence.
Holiday Planning: Myrtle’s popularity soars during holiday seasons, making advance ordering crucial for Thanksgiving and Christmas celebrations.
The extensive special-order menu offers options beyond the daily selections.
Myrtle’s Pies
📍 927 N Main St, Princeton, IL 61356
