- Attraction: Not As Famous Cookie Company
- Location: 1080 Windy Hill Rd SE #300, Smyrna, GA 30080
- Industry: Bakery
- Website: https://www.notasfamous.com
Step into Not As Famous Cookie Company and prepare for cookies that defy every expectation you’ve ever had about size, texture, and flavor intensity.
Owner Ashley Carlton brings generational recipes that have been refined for close to 40 years to this charming Smyrna storefront, where each cookie emerges as a dense, palm-sized masterpiece that somehow achieves perfect gooey centers without being underdone.
This Black-owned business started as a food truck in 2015 before graduating to its brick-and-mortar home in 2021, carrying forward a family legacy that began with Carlton’s father’s vision for exceptional gourmet cookies.
What started as a corporate departure dream has blossomed into Atlanta’s go-to destination for cookies that earn devoted fans from their very first bite.
Signature Cookie Creations
The Legendary Chocolate Chip: The first cookie Carlton ever sold and still the crown jewel of the menu, this isn’t your average chocolate chip experience. These goliath, super dense cookies somehow consistently achieve a gooey softness without being doughy or underdone.
Related
More in Georgia
See Why Food Lovers Drive Hours Into The Georgia Backwoods For Chef Jerome’s Legendary Seafood
Keep Exploring →You’ll discover they’re crunchy on the edges while maintaining that perfect chewy center that keeps customers coming back month after month.
Red Velvet Perfection: A mainstay on the menu that showcases the bakery’s mastery, this Georgia-inspired creation features a red velvet base studded with white chocolate chips that pays homage to the Peach State’s beloved flavor profile.
Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Pretzel: Carlton’s personal favorite combines sweet and salty flavors in perfect harmony, creating a sophisticated taste experience that elevates the humble cookie into gourmet territory.
Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup Delight: Featuring a chocolate base with Reese’s cups embedded inside and glazed with a peanut butter coating on top, this indulgent creation satisfies even the most serious chocolate-peanut butter cravings.
Monthly Flavor Adventures: A picture board by the register shows the flavors of the month, which always feature seasonal offerings like green Grinch cookies or fall sweet potato varieties.
More in Georgia
This Chocolatey Woodstock Bakery Doubles As A New York-Style Pizzeria Paradise
Discover MorePast favorites have included apple pie cookies that taste like “they literally dump an entire apple pie into the cookie batter,” honey bun, lemon blueberry, and special holiday creations.
Cookie Ice Cream Sandwiches: The shop serves as a paradise for people seeking cookie ice cream sandwiches, transforming their signature cookies into decadent frozen treats that combine the best of both dessert worlds.
Deep Dish Innovation: Available for those in the know who ask about them, these special creations offer an even more indulgent cookie experience for serious cookie enthusiasts.
Cookie Bowl Experience & Artisan Shakes
Cookie Bowls: Priced at $7, these creative presentations transform cookies into dessert bowls, perfect for those seeking an Instagram-worthy treat that tastes as good as it looks.
Handcrafted Shakes: Available for $10, these artisan shakes incorporate the bakery’s signature flavors into creamy, indulgent beverages that complement the cookie experience perfectly.
Related
More in Georgia
This Pooler Museum Is An Imaginary World Where Your Kids Can Be Shopkeepers And Fishermen
Keep Exploring →Take-and-Bake Options: For cookie lovers who want the fresh-baked experience at home, the bakery offers cookie dough that you can bake yourself, bringing that warm-from-the-oven magic to your own kitchen.
Atmosphere & Shop Experience
Aromatic Welcome: Walking into the shop, you’ll be enchanted by the smell of freshly baked goods seeping from the oven, creating an immediately inviting atmosphere that makes your mouth water before you even see the display.
Monthly Menu Boards: They rotate their menu monthly while keeping classics like chocolate chip available, with visual displays showing off the current selection and seasonal specialties that keep regulars excited about return visits.
Cozy Storefront Setting: The Smyrna location provides a welcoming neighborhood bakery feel, where the focus remains squarely on the artisanal quality of the cookies rather than flashy decor. The owner and workers are consistently pleasant and offer helpful recommendations to help you navigate the tempting options.
Family-Friendly Environment: The bakery offers a family-friendly atmosphere where everyone from young cookie monsters to sophisticated dessert lovers can find something to satisfy their cravings.
More in Georgia
See An Authentic World War II Bomber At This Incredible Museum Near Savannah
Discover MorePractical Considerations
Fair Pricing Structure: Individual cookies typically run around $3-4 each, with 6 cookies for $18 and a full dozen for $32, positioning the bakery as a mid-tier option that reflects the gourmet quality and generous sizing of each cookie.
Value Proposition: Given the huge, thick size and rich, buttery, salty-sweet flavor profiles, many customers find the pricing reasonable for the quality and portion size you receive.
Operating Hours: Open Wednesday through Sunday (closed Monday and Tuesday), with hours from 12:00 PM – 9:00 PM on Wednesday and Thursday, 12:00 PM – 10:00 PM on Friday and Saturday, and 12:00 PM – 7:00 PM on Sunday.
Multiple Ordering Options: The bakery accepts no cash but takes all major credit cards, as well as CashApp, Apple Pay, Google Pay, and offers delivery through DoorDash.
Catering Services: Available for private events, making these gourmet cookies perfect for office meetings, birthday parties, and special occasions where you want to make a memorable impression.
Related
More in Georgia
Hidden In Historic Parson’s Alley, This Duluth Gem Serves Meat Dishes That Fall Off The Bone
Keep Exploring →Parking & Location: Located in a shopping center on Windy Hill Road, parking is readily available, making it convenient for both quick stops and leisurely visits.
Best Times to Visit: Weekday afternoons and early evenings tend to offer the fullest selection, while weekend visits might find some seasonal flavors sold out due to their popularity.
Not As Famous Cookie Company
📍 1080 Windy Hill Rd SE #300, Smyrna, GA 30080
