- Attraction: Surfside Shakes
- Location: 111 3rd Street South, Flagler Beach, FL 32136
- Industry: Ice Cream Shop
- Website: https://www.surfsideshakes.com/
Discover the secret that locals have been keeping tucked away just one block from Flagler Beach’s iconic pier.
While most tourists walk right past this unassuming ice cream haven, those in the know make a beeline for what many consider the most creative and satisfying frozen treats on Florida’s coast.
This locally-owned shop isn’t your typical beach-side ice cream stand.
Behind its charming facade lies an operation serving premium Leopold’s craft ice cream—a renowned Georgia brand with roots stretching back to 1919—alongside an impressive array of signature shakes that have earned a devoted following among both locals and savvy visitors.
Signature Shake Creations
Sea Turtle Shake: The crown jewel of their menu combines hot fudge, butterscotch syrup, and roasted salted pecans blended into their premium soft serve. This thick, indulgent creation delivers layers of flavor that perfectly balance sweet and salty elements with a satisfying crunch.
Related
More in Florida
This St. Augustine Bakery Is A Must-Try For Anyone Who Wants A Truly Authentic French Croissant
Keep Exploring →Peanut Butter Explosion: True to its dramatic name, this powerhouse blend features hot fudge, peanut butter sauce, and chopped Reese’s peanut butter cups all swirled into their signature soft serve. You’ll find generous portions of mix-ins throughout every sip.
Flagler Luau: A tropical escape in a glass, featuring pineapple, banana, and toasted coconut flakes that transport you to island paradise. The combination creates a refreshing treat that’s perfectly suited to the coastal setting.
Mermaid Kisses: This whimsical creation captures childhood magic with cotton candy flavor and cotton candy crunch blended into vanilla soft serve. The result is both nostalgic and surprisingly sophisticated.
The Sandbox: Oreos blend seamlessly with premium soft serve, topped with whipped cream and gummy worms for a playful presentation that delights kids and adults alike.
Shark Bait Shake: Blue raspberry syrup creates an ocean-colored base topped with whipped cream, gummy sharks, and a drizzle of red raspberry sauce for an Instagram-worthy presentation.
More in Florida
Discover St. Petersburg’s Premier Rooftop With Unobstructed Views Of Tampa Bay
Discover MoreIce Cream & Sundae Excellence
Leopold’s Craft Ice Cream: You’ll taste the difference in every scoop of this Georgia-made premium ice cream. Flavors like Savannah Socialite feature milk and dark chocolate with roasted Georgia pecans and bourbon-infused caramel that showcases the brand’s Southern heritage.
Banana Split Perfection: Their banana splits arrive with soft serve, fresh bananas, hot fudge, caramel, pineapples, strawberries, homemade whipped cream, and crunchy peanuts. Each component maintains its distinct flavor while creating harmony in every bite.
Hot Fudge Brownie Sundae: Rich, decadent brownies pair with premium ice cream and generous hot fudge for an indulgence that satisfies the most serious chocolate cravings.
Seasonal Specialties: Look for limited-time creations like the Parrot Head Punch Shake during First Friday events, showcasing the creativity that sets this shop apart from typical beach ice cream stands.
Atmosphere & Location
Hidden Gem Status: Located one block from the Flagler Beach pier, this spot requires a bit of seeking out but rewards the effort. The somewhat tucked-away location on a side street means you’ll often find a more relaxed atmosphere compared to busier beachfront establishments.
Related
More in Florida
Most People Don’t Know This Secluded Slice Of Heaven Exists Near Port St. Joe
Keep Exploring →Outdoor Seating: Enjoy your treats at their outdoor seating area, or take your order across to the nearby boardwalk for seaside enjoyment. The setting perfectly complements the coastal flavors and beach town atmosphere.
Hometown Charm: The space maintains an authentic local feel that reminds you of old-fashioned farm-fresh ice cream experiences. You’ll appreciate the unpretentious atmosphere that focuses entirely on quality treats rather than flashy presentations.
Photo-Worthy Treats: The colorful, creative presentations make for excellent social media moments, with their artistic shake combinations and playful sundae arrangements.
Other Considerations
Pricing Value: You’ll find democratic pricing that offers excellent value for the premium ingredients and generous portions. Most shakes run around $8, which represents fair pricing for the quality and creativity you receive.
Perfect Sweetness Level: Unlike many ice cream shops that lean heavily sweet, Surfside achieves the ideal balance. Their treats satisfy without overwhelming, making them perfect for finishing a beach day meal.
More in Florida
This Florida State Park Was Created During The Great Depression And Features A Stunning Canyon-Like Landscape
Discover MoreYear-Round Operation: This locally-owned business maintains consistent hours throughout the year, even during quieter winter months when many seasonal establishments close.
Delivery Options: Available through major delivery platforms including DoorDash, Postmates, and Uber Eats for those wanting to enjoy these treats at their accommodations.
Dog-Friendly: Well-behaved pets are welcome, making this a perfect stop during beach walks with four-legged family members.
Takeout Focus: While seating is available, the setup works perfectly for grabbing treats to enjoy while exploring Flagler Beach’s attractions.
Competition Edge: In a town with multiple ice cream options, the creative flavor combinations and premium ingredients help this spot stand out as the most innovative choice.
Related
More in Florida
This Hollywood Waterfront Gem Serves “America’s Best Burger” From A Former Gas Station
Keep Exploring →Surfside Shakes
📍 111 3rd Street South, Flagler Beach, FL 32136
