- Attraction: Pickles New York Deli
- Location: 1891 W State Rd 434, Longwood, FL 32750
- Industry: Delicatessen
- Website: https://picklesnydeli.com/
Picture walking into a slice of authentic New York deli culture without leaving Central Florida.
Since 1997, Pickles New York Deli has been serving up genuine Big Apple flavors in an unassuming Longwood strip mall, earning recognition as one of Florida’s top 10 delicatessens with national elite status for their corned beef.
What sets this place apart isn’t just their commitment to authenticity—it’s their dedication to importing the real deal.
From Junior’s world-famous cheesecakes shipped directly from Brooklyn to Bronx water-boiled bagels, square knishes, and barrel pickles from Manhattan, every bite delivers the genuine New York experience that locals rave about as their all-time favorite lunch spot.
Signature Sandwiches & Deli Classics
The Legendary Reuben: You’ll discover why countless customers call this the “best Reuben sandwich in town.” Piled high with tender, hand-carved corned beef or pastrami straight from the steamer, tangy sauerkraut, melted Swiss cheese, and Russian dressing on authentic caraway-studded rye bread. The portions are massive—expect to have leftovers for lunch tomorrow.
Related
More in Florida
Witness A River Vanish Into Thin Air At This Historic High Springs State Park
Keep Exploring →Award-Winning Pastrami: The pastrami here isn’t just good—it’s award-winning. Sliced thin but generously portioned, it strikes the perfect balance between lean and fatty, delivering that authentic New York deli flavor that’ll transport you straight to the Lower East Side. Try it on the Brooklyn Reuben for an unforgettable combination.
The New Yorker: This towering sandwich has earned a devoted following among regulars who describe it as “incredible.” Packed with premium deli meats and fresh toppings, it’s a hearty meal that showcases everything great about traditional deli craftsmanship.
Bronx Cheer: A creative twist on the classic Reuben, swapping sauerkraut for creamy coleslaw. The combination of tender corned beef with the crisp, cool coleslaw creates a delightful contrast that even sauerkraut skeptics will love.
Turkey Pesto Panini: Grilled to perfection and served with au jus for dipping, this sandwich elevates the humble turkey sandwich into something special. The pesto adds a fresh, herby brightness that pairs beautifully with the tender turkey.
Authentic New York Specialties
Junior’s Cheesecake: The crown jewel of desserts here might just be the best cheesecake you’ll ever taste. Shipped directly from Brooklyn’s legendary Junior’s, each slice is creamy, rich, and absolutely indulgent—worth the trip alone.
More in Florida
Try Elvis’ Pink Cadillac Pancakes At This 1950s Gas Station-Themed Diner In St. Augustine
Discover MoreSquare Knishes from Brooklyn: These aren’t your average knishes. Pickles serves authentic Gabila’s knishes, widely considered among the best commercially available. Flaky pastry filled with seasoned potato that’s comfort food at its finest.
Barrel Pickles: The pickle bar is a must-see attraction that offers multiple varieties of Manhattan barrel pickles. Sample different styles and discover your favorite—from full sour to half sour varieties, each one garlicky, crunchy, and authentically New York.
Matzo Ball Soup: The lemon-infused chicken broth takes this Jewish comfort food to the next level. The matzo balls are perfectly fluffy, floating in a rich, flavorful broth that warms you from the inside out.
French Onion Soup: Surprisingly excellent for a deli, this soup features a rich, savory broth topped with melted cheese that’ll have you coming back for more.
Pizza & Italian Offerings
New York Style Pizza: Beyond deli classics, Pickles serves authentic NY-style pizza that locals describe as amazing. The thin crust and quality toppings prove this place does more than just sandwiches exceptionally well.
Related
More in Florida
This Cape Canaveral Museum Lets You Follow The Yellow Brick Road Right Into Van Gogh’s Starry Night
Keep Exploring →Italian Combo Hoagie: For those wanting something different, this sandwich packs cappicola, sopresata, Genoa salami, mozzarella, Italian peppers, lettuce, tomato, balsamic, and parmesan into one satisfying bite.
Atmosphere & Décor
Authentic New York Vibes: Step inside and you’ll feel transported to a genuine New York deli. The dining room pays homage to the Big Apple with murals and framed photos of NYC icons covering the walls, creating an atmosphere that’s both lively and nostalgic.
Indoor & Outdoor Seating: The spacious outdoor patio is perfect for Florida’s beautiful weather, while the indoor dining room maintains that classic deli atmosphere. Whether you’re soaking up sunshine or enjoying air conditioning, both spaces capture that authentic NYC energy.
Full Bar Experience: Unlike many delis, Pickles offers a complete bar featuring beer, wine, and cocktails. Brooklyn Brewery beers on tap add to the authentic experience, while the full bar makes it perfect for casual drinks with friends.
The Ladies’ Room Mural: Don’t miss the awesome mural in the ladies’ room—it’s become a talking point among visitors and adds to the restaurant’s unique character and attention to detail.
More in Florida
Slurp The Gulf’s Best Oysters At This Panama City Institution That’s Been Shucking Since 1966
Discover MoreOther Considerations
Generous Portions & Pricing: You’ll get exceptional value here with massive sandwiches that often provide two meals. The pricing feels reasonable for the quality and quantity you receive, especially considering the premium ingredients imported from New York.
Parking & Location: Conveniently located in a strip mall on State Road 434 right off I-4 exit 94, parking is plentiful and free. You’ll find it in the same shopping center as 4 Rivers Smokehouse, making it an easy stop.
Hours to Remember: They’re open Monday through Saturday from 9 AM to 8 PM (9 PM on weekends), and Sunday from 9 AM to 5 PM. Plan accordingly since they close earlier than many restaurants.
Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The restaurant welcomes families and groups, with outdoor seating that’s perfect for kids and a casual atmosphere that accommodates everyone from business lunches to family gatherings.
Takeout & Delivery: Available through multiple platforms including DoorDash and Uber Eats, though many customers recommend dining in for the full experience and to ensure sandwiches arrive at their peak freshness.
Related
More in Florida
This German Bakery In Yalaha Is Making The Most Authentic Black Forest Cake And Bee Sting Pastry In Florida
Keep Exploring →Catering Services: Pickles has been providing award-winning catering since 1997, making them a reliable choice for events where you want to impress with authentic New York deli fare.
Pickles New York Deli
📍 1891 W State Rd 434, Longwood, FL 32750
