Key Lime Pie Bakery - Key West, FL

Attraction: Key Lime Pie Bakery
Location: 412 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040
Industry: Bakery
Website: https://keylimepiebakery.com/

Walking into this bright yellow bakery feels like discovering a hidden treasure chest filled with citrus gold. Key Lime Pie Bakery boldly claims to be the “original” Key Lime Pie establishment in Key West, with roots stretching back to 1856, making it one of the most historic dessert destinations in the Florida Keys.

You’ll find this charming spot just one block off the famous Duval Street, positioned perfectly along the route most cruise ship visitors take during their Key West adventures. This locally owned and operated bakery specializes in fresh-baked Key Lime pie made daily for visitors, and what sets them apart is their commitment to authenticity.

You can actually watch the bakers create these citrusy masterpieces right in front of your eyes through the bakery’s open kitchen design. The cozy space features just a few small tables perfect for two people, creating an intimate setting where you can savor every tangy bite while soaking in the local Key West atmosphere.

Key Lime Creations That’ll Make Your Taste Buds Dance

The Classic Key Lime Pie: This traditional masterpiece features the perfect balance of flavor, consistency, and crust that defines what Key lime pie should be. You’ll taste the authentic tartness from real Key lime juice, not artificial flavoring, creating that distinctive bright and zesty flavor that captures the essence of Key West. The thick graham cracker crust provides the perfect foundation, while the smooth, creamy filling delivers that signature lime aftertaste that’ll have you craving more.

Key Lime Cheesecake: This variation combines the tangy lime flavor with rich, creamy cheesecake texture, making it a favorite among many visitors. The dessert offers a more indulgent twist on the classic, with the lime cutting through the richness beautifully. You’ll find this version particularly satisfying if you prefer a denser, more luxurious dessert experience.

Chocolate-Dipped Key Lime Pie: For those who can’t choose between chocolate and lime, this creation solves your dilemma perfectly. The traditional Key lime slice gets a generous coating of quality chocolate, creating a delightful contrast between the tart filling and sweet chocolate shell. They also offer Key lime pie on a stick, making it easy to enjoy while exploring the island.

Coconut Key Lime Combination: Their coconut cream pie and coconut key lime hybrid creation has earned rave reviews from visitors who describe it as “crazy delicious”. This tropical fusion brings together two beloved Florida flavors in one spectacular dessert that perfectly captures the island vibe.

Extra Tart Option: For lime lovers who prefer maximum tartness, they offer an “extra tart” version that’s more “lime-ee” than other Key West establishments. This version doesn’t hold back on the citrus punch, delivering an intense lime experience that serious Key lime pie enthusiasts absolutely adore.

Atmosphere & Sweet Shop Vibes

Charming Yellow Storefront: The well-lit yellow shop sits at the end of Greene Street, near Duval, making it easily recognizable. The bright, cheerful exterior perfectly matches the sunny disposition you’ll find inside, creating an inviting atmosphere that draws you in from the street.

Intimate Indoor Seating: The space is small, featuring just a few two-person tables alongside a gift shop and selection of sweets. This cozy setup creates a more personal dining experience compared to larger tourist restaurants, allowing you to truly focus on your dessert without distractions.

Step Inside The Sanibel Island Museum Where Science, Art, And Ocean Magic Collide

Discover More

Green Benches for People-Watching: You can hang out on their cute green benches out front, perfect for snapping photos and people-watching while eating your Key lime pie. This outdoor seating option lets you soak up the Key West street life while enjoying your treat.

Souvenir Shopping Paradise: The bakery carries a large selection of souvenirs that world travelers can take home to remember their visit to Key West. The shop bursts with every Key lime product, souvenir, trinket, and goodie you could ask for, all brilliantly organized and wonderfully decorated.

Other Considerations

Reasonable Pricing: Slice prices are quite reasonable at around $6 per piece, which is less than you’d pay in most restaurants, with whole pies available for about $30. Their prices either match or are cheaper than other Key lime product stores in the area, making it an excellent value for the quality you receive.

Perfect for Cruise Ship Visitors: Located just a few blocks from the cruise port and right on the path frequented by most cruise ship visitors, this bakery offers convenient access for those with limited time in port. You can easily grab a slice or whole pie to enjoy during your brief Key West adventure.

Takeout and Shipping Options: The bakery offers excellent takeout service, and if you find yourself craving Key lime after your trip to Key West, they’ll ship you a whole pie through their online catalog. This means you can bring the taste of Key West home with you or send gifts to friends and family.

Coffee Pairings: You get a free cup of coffee with every piece of pie, though on those sweltering Key West days, you might prefer to skip the hot beverage and focus on the cool, refreshing pie instead.

Best Times to Visit: The bakery operates seven days a week, making it convenient for any day of your Key West visit. Since they bake fresh daily, arriving earlier in the day ensures the best selection and freshest options.

Family-Friendly Atmosphere: The small, intimate setting works well for families, couples, or solo travelers looking for an authentic Key West dessert experience without the crowds of larger tourist establishments.

Key Lime Pie Bakery
📍 412 Greene St, Key West, FL 33040