- Attraction: Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop
- Location: 200A Elizabeth St, Key West, FL 33040
- Industry: Dessert Shop
- Website: https://www.kermitskeylime.com
Picture biting into a frozen slice of key lime pie wrapped in rich Belgian chocolate while sitting beside a tranquil koi pond in the heart of Key West’s historic seaport.
At Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop, this dreamy scenario becomes reality as you discover why Food Network and National Geographic have crowned this vibrant green-and-yellow shop the ultimate destination for authentic key lime treats.
Founded in 1993 by Kermit Carpenter, this iconic establishment has evolved from a humble smoothie stand into Key West’s most beloved dessert destination.
You’ll find yourself immersed in a key lime wonderland featuring over 120 different products, from the shop’s legendary pies to unexpected delights like key lime BBQ sauce and even key lime chapstick.
The original location sits perfectly positioned at the corner of Elizabeth and Greene Streets, just steps from the marina where you might catch glimpses of sharks swimming by.
Related
More in Florida
Dive Into 4,000 Years Of Underwater Adventure At This Fascinating Islamorada Museum
Keep Exploring →Signature Key Lime Creations
The Classic Key Lime Pie: You’ll taste perfection in every bite of Kermit’s traditional key lime pie. The graham cracker crust provides the perfect foundation for a silky-smooth filling that strikes an ideal balance between tart lime zing and creamy sweetness. Light dollops of whipped cream crown each slice without overwhelming the authentic flavors beneath.
Chocolate-Dipped Pie on a Stick: This frozen masterpiece transforms the classic pie experience into something magical. Each slice gets enrobed in rich Belgian chocolate and served on a convenient stick, creating what many consider the ultimate Key West treat. The contrast between the cold, creamy interior and the satisfying chocolate crunch makes every bite unforgettable.
Coconut Key Lime Pie: Transport yourself to a tropical paradise with this island-inspired variation. The coconut adds an extra layer of exotic flavor that perfectly complements the tart lime, creating what tastes like a vacation in every forkful.
Strawberry Key Lime Combination: You’ll discover an unexpected harmony when sweet strawberry meets tangy key lime. This creative twist comes dipped in white chocolate, offering a beautiful pink-and-white presentation that’s as Instagram-worthy as it is delicious.
Key Lime Ice Cream: Cool down with scoops of the island’s best key lime ice cream. The creamy texture carries intense lime flavor that refreshes your palate on hot Florida days.
More in Florida
Indulge In Authentic Paella And Famous Sangria At Celebration’s Beloved Columbia Restaurant
Discover MoreBeyond the Pie
Sampling Galore: You’ll love exploring the shop’s extensive selection through generous free samples. Taste everything from key lime salsa and BBQ sauce to jellies and chocolates before making your selections.
Unique Key Lime Products: Discover unexpected treasures like key lime salad dressing, olive oil, honey, and even bath products. The key lime salt scrub has become a particular favorite among visitors looking to take the Keys experience home.
Kermit’s Kitchen Café: Satisfy your appetite with a full breakfast and lunch menu served until 3 PM daily. The award-winning Cuban sandwich, wraps, salads, and hearty soups provide perfect savory complements to your sweet treats.
Atmosphere & Setting
Peaceful Garden Oasis: You’ll find serenity in the charming outdoor seating area complete with a koi pond, waterfall features, and lush tropical plants. This hidden garden provides a welcome escape from Key West’s bustling energy.
Historic Seaport Location: The shop’s prime position near the marina and Mallory Square puts you in the heart of Key West’s most vibrant area. You can easily combine your visit with waterfront strolling and sunset watching.
Related
More in Florida
Spray Paint, Sculptures, And Surprises: Stroll Through Miami’s Ever-Changing Murals At Wynwood Walls
Keep Exploring →Bright and Cheerful Interior: The lime-green and yellow color scheme creates an instantly recognizable landmark that radiates tropical cheerfulness. Everything from the walls to the merchandise screams “Florida Keys fun.”
Instagram-Perfect Moments: Watch for Kermit himself, who’s often spotted playfully tossing pies with tourists near Mallory Square, creating memorable photo opportunities that capture the spirit of Key West.
Other Considerations
Tourist-Friendly Pricing: You’ll find slices priced around $6 plus tax, which represents reasonable value for Key West standards. Whole pies offer better value if you’re planning to share or take treats back to your accommodation.
Quality vs. Convenience: The pies are pre-made and properly chilled rather than fresh-from-the-oven, ensuring food safety and consistent quality. This commercial approach means you’re getting reliably excellent pie rather than hit-or-miss homemade versions.
Multiple Locations: You’ll find a second Kermit’s location on Duval Street for quick grab-and-go treats, plus many local restaurants proudly serve Kermit’s pie by the slice throughout Key West.
More in Florida
You Won’t Believe The Rainbows Dancing On The Water At This Florida Gem!
Discover MoreShipping Options: Take the Key West experience home through their nationwide shipping service. Orders over $75 qualify for free ground shipping, making it easy to surprise friends and family with authentic Key lime treats.
Family-Friendly Experience: The welcoming atmosphere and sampling opportunities make this an ideal stop for families with children who want to explore new flavors in a relaxed setting.
Peak Hours: Expect crowds during prime tourist times, but the efficient service and multiple seating areas help minimize wait times. Early morning or late afternoon visits often provide a more leisurely experience.
Kermit’s Key Lime Pie Shop
📍 200A Elizabeth St, Key West, FL 33040
