Posted in

This Jacksonville Ice Cream Shop Makes Over 150 Flavors, And They’re Churned Fresh Daily

  • Attraction: Bruster’s Real Ice Cream
  • Location: 12224 Atlantic Blvd, Jacksonville, FL 32225
  • Industry: Ice Cream Shop
  • Website: https://brusters.com

What began as a single Pennsylvania family business in 1989 has transformed into a beloved ice cream destination where Jacksonville locals can taste what happens when passion meets premium ingredients.

Bruster’s Real Ice Cream operates three locations across Jacksonville, each serving freshly made ice cream crafted daily by certified ice cream makers who follow time-honored recipes that have delighted families for over three decades.

Unlike mass-produced alternatives, every scoop at Bruster’s starts with a proprietary homestyle mix delivered fresh from their Pennsylvania dairy, ensuring you experience ice cream that’s never been hard-frozen and maintains that signature creamy texture that keeps customers coming back for more.

Signature Flavors & Daily Creations

Rotating Selection: With over 150 recipes in their arsenal and at least 24 flavors made fresh daily, you’ll discover something new with every visit. Popular standouts include the loaded cookie dough packed with generous chunks, deep dish apple pie that tastes like dessert heaven, and nutty coconut that delivers tropical bliss in every bite.

Seasonal Specialties: Throughout the year, you’ll find limited-time flavors like pumpkin during fall, fresh peach in summer, and winter wonder when the holidays arrive. These rotating selections ensure that regular visitors always have something exciting to anticipate.

See Why This Unique Food Hall In Orlando Is Home To Some Of The Best Cookies On Planet Earth Related

More in Florida

See Why This Unique Food Hall In Orlando Is Home To Some Of The Best Cookies On Planet Earth

Keep Exploring →

Unique Creations: Adventure-seekers rave about boldly named flavors like Purple Dinosaur, while traditionalists consistently praise classics like mint chocolate chip loaded with real chocolate pieces and butter pecan featuring whole pecan halves rather than tiny crumbs.

Cookie Butter & Cake Batter: Two exceptional flavor options, the cookie butter delivers rich, spreadable cookie flavor while cake batter tastes exactly like licking the bowl after baking your favorite birthday cake.

Blueberry Vanilla Swirl: This standout combines vanilla ice cream with ribbons of real blueberry and cookie pieces, creating what many describe as the perfect flavor combination.

Treats Beyond Basic Scoops

Waffle Cones & Bowls: Their handmade waffle cones are baked fresh daily, providing a crispy, sweet vessel that perfectly complements any flavor choice. The waffle bowls are particularly popular for their generous size and ability to hold multiple scoops.

Blasts & Sundaes: These signature creations blend your chosen ice cream with mix-ins like cookies, candies, and sauces, creating customized treats that satisfy any sweet tooth. The turtle sundae featuring vanilla ice cream smothered in hot fudge, caramel, whipped cream, and whole pecans exemplifies their commitment to quality ingredients.

Set Your Eyes On Giant Scoops Of Ice Cream At This Bright Santa Rosa Beach Parlor

More in Florida

Set Your Eyes On Giant Scoops Of Ice Cream At This Bright Santa Rosa Beach Parlor

Discover More

Banana Splits: Their classic banana splits transport you back to childhood with fresh fruit, multiple ice cream flavors, and traditional toppings. Thursdays offer a special promotion where bringing your own banana gets you half-price splits.

Milkshakes & Freezes: Hand-spun milkshakes are thick enough to stand a spoon in, while their freezes offer dairy-free alternatives without compromising on flavor intensity.

Custom Ice Cream Cakes: Perfect for celebrations, these made-to-order cakes feature your favorite flavors and can be customized for any occasion.

Atmosphere & Location Details

Outdoor Seating Focus: All Jacksonville locations feature primarily outdoor seating, making them perfect for Florida’s beautiful weather but less ideal during summer heat or rainy periods. The Atlantic Boulevard location sits conveniently under an overpass in the BJ’s shopping plaza.

Family-Friendly Environment: The casual atmosphere attracts families with children, couples on date nights, and anyone seeking a relaxed setting to enjoy premium ice cream. Multiple locations offer easy access from major Jacksonville roads.

Bring Your Own Catch To This Islamorada Restaurant And Let The Chefs Cook It For You Related

More in Florida

Bring Your Own Catch To This Islamorada Restaurant And Let The Chefs Cook It For You

Keep Exploring →

Drive-Through Convenience: Some locations feature drive-through service, allowing you to satisfy ice cream cravings without leaving your air-conditioned car during hot Florida summers.

Clean & Simple: The shops maintain a straightforward, clean aesthetic that puts the focus squarely on the ice cream rather than flashy décor, creating a comfortable environment for all ages.

Other Considerations

Value Pricing: Most customers find Bruster’s offers excellent value, with generous portion sizes that often surprise first-time visitors. A single scoop provides substantial satisfaction, while specialty items like banana splits easily serve two people.

Pet-Friendly Perks: Dog owners love the complimentary pup cups available for furry friends, making Bruster’s a popular stop during family outings that include four-legged members.

Dietary Options: The menu includes vegan non-dairy oat milk flavors, no-sugar-added varieties, and Italian ice options, ensuring most dietary preferences can be accommodated without sacrificing taste quality.

The Best Way To Beat The Florida Heat Is With A Layered Gelati From This Orange Park Favorite

More in Florida

The Best Way To Beat The Florida Heat Is With A Layered Gelati From This Orange Park Favorite

Discover More

Parking Availability: Located in shopping plazas with ample parking, you’ll rarely struggle to find a convenient spot, even during busy weekend evenings.

Peak Time Considerations: Summer afternoons and weekends typically see the highest crowds, but the efficient service keeps wait times reasonable. Winter months offer a quieter experience with the same quality products.

Seasonal Hours: Operating hours extend later during weekends (10:30 PM Friday-Saturday versus 10:00 PM other days), accommodating late-night ice cream cravings.


Bruster’s Real Ice Cream
📍 12224 Atlantic Blvd, Jacksonville, FL 32225

Writer: Jamie Benson
Click to read bio

Jamie grew up just outside of Springfield, Illinois, and has spent most of his life exploring the state’s mix of small-town charm and big-city energy. After earning a journalism degree from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, he stuck around to cover local events, hidden gems, and the quirks that make Illinois unique. When not writing, Jamie can usually be found digging through vinyl at record shops in Chicago, hiking trails in Starved Rock State Park, or tracking down the best deep-dish pizza outside the city.