Posted in

This High Springs Ice Cream Shop Feels Like A Sweet Time Machine To Simpler Days

Time stands still the moment you walk through the doors of this enchanting ice cream parlor that’s been capturing hearts since 2019.

With over 24 locally-made flavors rotating through their vintage-inspired freezers, Florida Creamery High Springs transforms a simple dessert stop into a full sensory journey back to simpler times.

Owner Angela Wilcox has created something truly special here – a place where freshly-made waffle cones, nostalgic memorabilia, and small-town charm blend together into an experience that leaves you planning your return visit before you’ve even finished your scoop.

Whether you’re seeking refuge from a day of exploring High Springs’ famous freshwater springs or looking for the perfect family treat after dinner, this delightful creamery delivers both exceptional ice cream and an atmosphere that makes every visit feel like a celebration.

Ice Cream Flavors & Signature Treats

The Blueberry Cheesecake: This standout flavor has earned a devoted following for good reason. Rich, creamy, and bursting with authentic cheesecake flavor, it’s topped with real blueberry swirls that taste like they came straight from a homemade pie. Served in one of their fresh waffle cones, it becomes an unforgettable treat.

Watch Live Artists Paint While You Feast On Gator Bites At This Creative Orlando Restaurant Related

More in Florida

Watch Live Artists Paint While You Feast On Gator Bites At This Creative Orlando Restaurant

Keep Exploring →

Unique Specialty Flavors: Beyond traditional favorites like butter pecan and chocolate, you’ll discover adventurous options like toasted coconut, pistachio, and peanut butter chocolate. The selection includes rotating unique combinations that keep regular visitors coming back to try something new.

Dairy-Free & Dietary Options: The creamery takes pride in offering locally-made dairy-free flavors that change regularly. Popular options include chocolate peanut butter and coconut almond fudge that tastes remarkably like an Almond Joy candy bar. They also feature sugar-free and low-fat options, ensuring everyone can find their perfect scoop.

Handmade Waffle Cones: You can watch as fresh waffle cones are made right before your eyes, filling the shop with an irresistible sweet aroma. These golden, crispy cones provide the perfect vessel for their creamy scoops and add an extra layer of freshness to every order.

Classic Banana Splits: Their generous banana splits arrive loaded with toppings and enough ice cream to satisfy any sweet tooth. Each split is carefully assembled with attention to both presentation and portion size, making them perfect for sharing or conquering solo.

Milkshakes & Sundaes: Rich milkshakes blend perfectly with their premium ice cream, while hot fudge sundaes arrive dripping with warm sauce and topped with whipped cream and a cherry. The milk shakes achieve that perfect thick consistency that requires a spoon.

Plummet Seven Stories In Eight Seconds On The “Brain Drain” At This Riviera Beach Water Park

More in Florida

Plummet Seven Stories In Eight Seconds On The “Brain Drain” At This Riviera Beach Water Park

Discover More

Atmosphere & Nostalgic Charm

Vintage Memorabilia Wonderland: The walls showcase an eclectic collection of Florida memorabilia, vintage art, and nostalgic collectibles that provide endless entertainment while you enjoy your treats. Every corner reveals new treasures to discover, from retro candy displays to vintage toys that spark childhood memories.

Interactive Entertainment: Trivia games at each table add an engaging element to your visit, making it perfect for families or couples looking to extend their stay. The questions range from local history to pop culture, encouraging conversation and laughter.

Music & Ambiance: Carefully curated background music enhances the throwback atmosphere, making you feel like you’ve stepped into a different era. The combination of sights and sounds creates an immersive experience that transports you away from the modern world.

Collectible Shopping: The shop doubles as a treasure hunt with various collectibles, vintage candies, M&M dispensers, and unique souvenirs available for purchase. Many visitors return specifically to add to collections they started on previous visits.

Cozy Seating Areas: Multiple indoor tables provide comfortable spots to savor your ice cream while taking in all the visual details. The intimate setting encourages you to slow down and fully enjoy the experience rather than rushing through.

Dare To Drop 200 Feet On SheiKra Or Race Cheetahs At This Incredible Tampa Park Related

More in Florida

Dare To Drop 200 Feet On SheiKra Or Race Cheetahs At This Incredible Tampa Park

Keep Exploring →

Other Considerations

Family-Friendly Pricing: The creamery maintains reasonable prices that make it accessible for families wanting to treat everyone without breaking the budget. You’ll find the portions generous and the quality exceptional for the cost, making it an excellent value.

Perfect Location: Situated right on Highway 27 in downtown High Springs, it’s easily accessible whether you’re a local or visiting the area’s famous springs. The convenient location makes it a natural stop during any High Springs adventure.

Parking & Accessibility: Street parking is readily available, and the shop’s location makes it easy to spot and access. The compact size creates a cozy feel without becoming uncomfortably crowded.

Sample Before You Choose: The generous policy of allowing customers to taste flavors before deciding helps ensure you’ll love your selection. This personal touch reflects the small-town hospitality that makes the experience special.

Seasonal Considerations: While the shop maintains comfortable indoor temperatures, the nostalgic atmosphere and cold treats provide the perfect antidote to Florida’s warm climate year-round. Summer visits are especially refreshing after outdoor activities.

Discover “Florida’s Most Beautiful Mile” At This Stunning Riverwalk In Fort Lauderdale

More in Florida

Discover “Florida’s Most Beautiful Mile” At This Stunning Riverwalk In Fort Lauderdale

Discover More

Hours & Timing: Open daily from noon until 8 PM (9 PM on weekends), with the busiest times typically occurring during late afternoon and early evening. Visiting during off-peak hours allows for a more leisurely experience and better photo opportunities.


Florida Creamery High Springs
📍 23629 W Highway 27, High Springs, FL 32643

Writer: Jamie Benson
Click to read bio

Jamie grew up just outside of Springfield, Illinois, and has spent most of his life exploring the state’s mix of small-town charm and big-city energy. After earning a journalism degree from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, he stuck around to cover local events, hidden gems, and the quirks that make Illinois unique. When not writing, Jamie can usually be found digging through vinyl at record shops in Chicago, hiking trails in Starved Rock State Park, or tracking down the best deep-dish pizza outside the city.