Posted in

This 1891 Building In Tampa Is Now A Bookstore-Brunch Dream Straight Out Of Pinterest

Published: June 11, 2025

Lightning struck Tampa’s Hyde Park neighborhood in 2012 when Blake Casper and Allison Adams transformed a forgotten 1891 stable into what Architectural Digest named Florida’s most beautiful independent store and one of the 50 most beautiful in the nation.

This isn’t just another restaurant – Oxford Exchange is where literary souls meet culinary adventurers in a space that feels like stepping into a London gentleman’s club that decided to serve the most incredible brunch in Florida.

Originally built as a stable for the historic Tampa Bay Hotel, this architectural gem now houses a restaurant, bookstore, coffee bar, tea room, champagne bar, gift shop, and coworking space all under one magnificently restored roof.

The building’s century-old masonry walls create an atmosphere so striking that you’ll understand why over 700 couples have chosen this as their wedding venue since opening.

Brunch That’s Worth the Instagram Fame

French Toast Perfection: You’ll discover what many consider the best French toast in Tampa – thick, decadent slices that taste like banana foster without the ice cream.

Your Passport To Southeast Asian Flavors Awaits At This Critically Acclaimed Hollywood Restaurant Related

More in Florida

Your Passport To Southeast Asian Flavors Awaits At This Critically Acclaimed Hollywood Restaurant

Keep Exploring →

The rich, custard-soaked bread is so indulgent that finishing a full order becomes a delicious challenge you’ll gladly accept.

The Famous Brunch Tower: This architectural marvel of morning indulgence stacks multiple brunch favorites into one impressive presentation.

You’ll get layers of flavors and textures that make for both an incredible meal and the kind of photo that stops people mid-scroll on social media.

Signature Flatbreads: The brunch flatbread combines whipped boursin, gouda, a perfectly sunny-side egg, bacon, spinach, marinated tomatoes, and hot honey into something that tastes like breakfast decided to get fancy.

Each bite delivers a perfect balance of creamy, savory, and sweet.

Step Back Into 1856 And Touch Real Treasure At This Historic Key West Museum

More in Florida

Step Back Into 1856 And Touch Real Treasure At This Historic Key West Museum

Discover More

Eggs Benedict Excellence: The salmon eggs benedict arrives with a hollandaise sauce that has hints of chicken gravy (trust us, it’s brilliant) and sits atop an English muffin that actually holds up to the generous toppings.

The breakfast potatoes are good, but insider tip: upgrade to the sweet potato fries with their incredible garlic and orange dipping sauces.

Tea Service Like No Other: You can choose from TeBella Tea Co.’s wall of loose teas with four daily specials, including the beloved carrot cake tea that tastes like comfort in a cup.

The tea service comes in proper tabletop pots that provide enough for sharing, making it perfect for lingering conversations.

Local Favorites: The whipped feta appetizer has earned a devoted following among locals who call it one of the best Mediterranean plates they’ve ever experienced.

Under A Giant Thatched Roof, Lucky Fish Serves Legendary Eats Right On Pompano Beach Related

More in Florida

Under A Giant Thatched Roof, Lucky Fish Serves Legendary Eats Right On Pompano Beach

Keep Exploring →

The cauliflower bisque and fall flatbread consistently earn rave reviews for being both filling and extraordinarily flavorful.

A Feast for All Your Senses

The Glass Conservatory: You’ll dine under a retractable glass roof surrounded by creeping vines and natural plants that create an almost greenhouse-like atmosphere.

Natural light floods this space, making every meal feel like you’re dining in a secret garden.

Historic Meets Modern: The exposed brick walls, Edison bulb lighting, and carefully preserved masonry from 1891 create a backdrop that feels both industrial and elegant.

You’ll notice how the designers respected the building’s history while adding contemporary touches that make the space feel alive and current.

An Orlando Steakhouse Serves Up Unforgettable Filet Mignon And A Colossal Crown Onion

More in Florida

An Orlando Steakhouse Serves Up Unforgettable Filet Mignon And A Colossal Crown Onion

Discover More

The Champagne Bar: This maximalist space bursts with pink and red shades, lush fabrics, and exuberant textures. You can sip champagne, rosé, or select cocktails while browsing through the adjacent gift shop, creating a luxurious intermission during your visit.

Literary Atmosphere: The bookstore features carefully curated selections displayed against striking black and white shelving that makes the books pop visually.

You’ll find everything from bestsellers to classics, including some of Florida’s banned books, creating conversations that extend well beyond your meal.

Art-Filled Spaces: Every corner offers something visually interesting, from historical photographs of Tampa figures to contemporary art installations.

The open kitchen design lets you watch the culinary magic happen while floor-to-ceiling windows provide views of the University of Tampa’s distinctive minarets.

From Grouper Fingers To Live Music, This Seafood Shack Defines Old Florida Related

More in Florida

From Grouper Fingers To Live Music, This Seafood Shack Defines Old Florida

Keep Exploring →

Other Considerations

Pricing Expectations: You’ll find prices on the higher side – expect to spend around $75 for two people for brunch without alcohol.

While it’s definitely a splurge, most visitors agree the experience, atmosphere, and food quality justify the cost. The portions are generous and the presentation rivals upscale restaurants.

Reservation Strategy: Weekend brunch requires advance reservations as this place stays consistently busy. You can book through their website or OpenTable, where they’re recognized as one of the top 100 brunch restaurants in America.

Arriving right at opening on weekdays offers a more peaceful experience.

Parking Reality: You’ll deal with typical downtown Tampa parking challenges. There’s metered street parking and paid lots within walking distance.

Budget an extra $8-10 for parking and a few extra minutes to find a spot, especially on weekends.

Noise Levels: The space can get quite lively during peak brunch hours, making conversation challenging at times.

The vibrant energy is part of the appeal for many, but if you prefer quieter dining, consider weekday breakfast or early weekend arrival.

Family Considerations: While beautiful, this isn’t specifically geared toward families with young children.

There’s no kids menu, and the sophisticated atmosphere is better suited for older children and adults who can appreciate the unique setting.

Multi-Experience Destination: Plan extra time to explore beyond just dining.

You can make candles at their Candle Pour station, browse the bookstore and gift shop, grab coffee from Buddy Brew, or simply wander through the different spaces.

Many visitors easily spend 2-3 hours here.


Oxford Exchange
📍 420 W Kennedy Blvd, Tampa, FL 33606

Writer: Jamie Benson
Contributor

Jamie grew up just outside of Springfield, Illinois, and has spent most of his life exploring the state’s mix of small-town charm and big-city energy. After earning a journalism degree from the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, he stuck around to cover local events, hidden gems, and the quirks that make Illinois unique. When not writing, Jamie can usually be found digging through vinyl at record shops in Chicago, hiking trails in Starved Rock State Park, or tracking down the best deep-dish pizza outside the city.