- Attraction: Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop
- Location: 3000 E Ray Rd Building 6, suite 103, Gilbert, AZ 85296 (located within Barnone)
- Industry: Ice Cream Shop
- Website: https://www.creamofthecrop-az.com/
Most ice cream shops stick to predictable flavors like vanilla and chocolate, but Cream of the Crop transforms frozen desserts into edible art with inspirations ranging from Van Gogh paintings to deconstructed childhood cereals.
Located inside the artisan community of Barnone at Agritopia, this progressive ice cream shop represents the creative collaboration between James Johnston and Matt Celaya, friends who turned a decade-old KitchenAid ice cream maker gift into Gilbert’s most innovative dessert destination.
Since opening in 2021, this small-batch operation has redefined what ice cream can be, using locally sourced ingredients and artistic inspiration to create flavors that challenge expectations while delivering impossibly creamy 16% butterfat indulgence.
Signature Creative Flavors
Van Gogh Masterpiece Series: The kitchen’s artistic approach reaches its peak with paint-inspired flavors like “Starry Night,” naturally colored with spirulina to recreate the swirling blues of the famous painting in edible form.
Cream of the Crop Signature: The shop’s namesake flavor features sweet cream and vanilla bean with an unexpected hint of lime that creates a refreshing twist on traditional vanilla base.
Related
More in Arizona
Part Bookstore, Part Bar, All Vibes: This Phoenix Literary Hotspot Is Unlike Anywhere Else
Keep Exploring →Meyer Lemon Cream Pie: Arizona Meyer lemon ice cream swirled with Meyer lemon curd and cinnamon graham crunchies that perfectly capture the essence of the classic dessert.
Burnt Honey Sensation: A sophisticated flavor that showcases the complexity possible when simple ingredients meet expert technique and creative vision.
Shake N Fries Innovation: This playful creation demonstrates the shop’s ability to transform unexpected concepts into surprisingly delicious frozen treats.
Captain Crunch Deconstruction: Childhood cereal reimagined as sophisticated ice cream that maintains nostalgic appeal while elevating the experience.
Peixoto Coffee Perfection: Featuring locally sourced coffee from Mythical Coffee in Gilbert, this flavor supports local businesses while delivering intense caffeine satisfaction.
More in Arizona
Dig For Gold, Meet Dinosaurs, And Travel Through Time At This Incredible Mesa Museum
Discover MorePremium Preparation & Techniques
16% Butterfat Luxury: Unlike typical grocery store ice cream (10-12% butterfat), this higher fat content creates impossibly creamy consistency that serves as the perfect canvas for complex flavors.
Stoelting Machine Excellence: Professional-grade equipment ensures consistent quality and texture that rivals the finest gelaterias and artisan ice cream shops anywhere.
Brûlée Service Option: Your ice cream is topped with sugar that’s torched tableside, creating a crispy, bubbly finish while keeping the ice cream perfectly frozen – a theatrical dessert experience.
The Fried Specialty: Scoops rolled in cornflake, cinnamon, and sugar mixture, then coated with hot honey and topped with whipped cream, creating carnival-quality treats that surpass typical deep-fried ice cream.
Small Batch Philosophy: Limited production ensures freshness and allows for experimental flavors that wouldn’t be possible with mass production methods.
Related
More in Arizona
This Hidden Mountain Spot Offers The Most Breathtaking View You’ll Get In All Of Phoenix
Keep Exploring →Local Ingredient Focus
Agritopia Farm Partnership: Many ingredients come directly from the organic farm surrounding the shop, ensuring peak freshness and supporting sustainable agriculture practices.
Mint Chocolate Chip Authenticity: Fresh mint grown on Agritopia farms creates a clean, natural mint flavor that distinguishes this classic from artificial alternatives.
Seasonal Availability: Rotating flavors reflect what’s currently growing and available locally, making each visit a potential discovery of new taste combinations.
Community Business Support: Partnerships with local producers like Mythical Coffee demonstrate commitment to strengthening Gilbert’s artisan food community.
Vegan Options: Dark chocolate sorbet with cocoa nibs and sea salt provides dairy-free indulgence without compromising on richness or complexity.
More in Arizona
Sip Signature Concoctions In This Low-Key Lounge That’s Home To Phoenix’s Finest Mixologists
Discover MoreArtistic Atmosphere & Design
Retro-Meets-Cartoon Aesthetic: Confetti-speckled countertops on breeze blocks, turquoise metal stools, and playful design elements create an Instagram-worthy environment.
Japanese Toy Collection: Wooden shelves lined with collectibles add whimsical touches that reflect the owners’ artistic sensibilities and attention to detail.
Origami Crane Installation: A flock of paper cranes suspended overhead creates visual interest while reinforcing the shop’s commitment to handcrafted artistry.
Neon Sign Statement: The playful “Cream of the Crop” sign serves as both functional lighting and artistic focal point that draws customers deeper into the experience.
Barnone Community: Located within a collective of 11 Arizona makers, the shop benefits from foot traffic generated by wood artists, pizzerias, and other creative businesses.
Related
More in Arizona
Sweet Meets Savory At This Phoenix Burger Joint That’s Redefining What A Burger Can Be
Keep Exploring →Practical Information
Limited Hours: Monday-Thursday 12-9 PM, Friday 12-9:30 PM, Saturday 11 AM-9:30 PM, closed Sundays, creating exclusivity that enhances the special occasion feel.
Barnone Location: Inside the artisan community at Agritopia, making it part of a larger cultural and culinary destination that encourages extended visits.
Premium Pricing: Reflects the high-quality ingredients, small-batch production, and artisanal approach while remaining accessible for special treats and celebrations.
Parking Availability: Adequate parking within the Barnone complex ensures convenient access without the stress common at popular Gilbert destinations.
Group-Friendly: The casual atmosphere and shareable portions make it perfect for family outings, dates, and small group celebrations.
Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop
📍 3000 E Ray Rd, Bldg 6, Gilbert, AZ 85296
